Was Aniston Forced to Make Sophie's Choice?

Let's put on our pet detective hats for a moment, shall we?

The buzz is ... John Mayer dumped Jen Aniston. But how to know? Look closely at the photo of Jen at a friend's house in Bev Hills taken yesterday ... see the two dogs on the grassy knoll? They could unlock the mystery.

We're hearing the dogs, especially Norman (the little one) was a John hater, and Jen loves that pooch.

So if she had to choose....



Reader Comments

(Page 6 of 8) Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

76. Wait-JOHN MAYER HATES DOGS?!?!?
I think that is absolutely DEPLORABLE & REPREHNSIBLE.
It figures LOONIES support JOHN MAYER THE ANIMAL HATER-
THEY ALSO SUPPORT ANGELINA THE ANIMAL HATER /SELF-PROFESSED ANIMAL KILLER.
Way to continue to demonstrate your flawed judgement LOONIES!

Posted at 8:42PM on Aug 13th 2008 by ALERT PETA

77. Nobody said John Mayer hates dogs. Nobody said John Mayer said that John told Jennifer, "It is either Norman or me." Nobody said Angelina Jolie said she hates animals/dogs. The animals "she killed" that you site, were talked about in a video that was released and recorded sometime in the early 1990's when she was still a teenager and she only said that some of her pets died, like a hampster that she gave a bath, when she was 6 years old!!! Are you seriously going to blame a 6 year old child for the death of one of their pets and CLAIM IT TO BE AN ADULT ANIMAL SACRAFICE OF SOME SORT?
Who is the friggin loonie here?

TMZ is claiming they split over the fact that Jennifer's dog, Norman, did not like John. That is all. TMZ speculating about what went wrong! Nobody said John Mayer hates dogs or that he made Jennifer choose him or the dang dog!! It is merely ALUDED TO BY TMZ STAFFERS!!! It is for a dumb HEADLINE! And trust me, PETA is well aware of the existance of this video of Angelina and yet, they do not picket her! Probably, because they heard, as it says, that she was a 6 year old child at the time she had some pets die!!!

Posted at 10:29PM on Aug 13th 2008 by The Dog said WOOF!

78. Regarding Jennifer Aniston:

I find it disturbing yet fascinating that there's so much hatred for a woman whose only "crime" was being cheated on by her husband.

Seriously, Brangelina fans...what exactly did Aniston do to make you hate her so much?

Posted at 8:08PM on Aug 19th 2008 by Sheesh!

79. Jennifer Aniston can pick and choose whom she wants to bang.........that is really all she is looking for at this point.There is no way that a female with her wealth, perfectly flawless tight buff little hot bod would pick a little wienie like John Mayer for a serious relationship!!!!!!!!!Come on she was married to Brad Pitt.....who in the hell will ever be able to compete with that?She seems pretty content with herself and her life .Good for her for just hanging out and doing whomever she desires!!!!!!!Go for it Jen you only live once.Aren't ya glad it is Angie and Brad with the 6 snot nose brats and NOT you and Brad.That would have been a "buzz-kill"!!!!!

Posted at 10:43PM on Aug 13th 2008 by Heeeere's Johnny

80. She made the RIGHT choice.....that dog knows something about John....

Posted at 10:44PM on Aug 13th 2008 by Animals Have Rights, Too!

81. Brad may have said, when he was with Jennifer Aniston, that he loves living in L.A. He may have even said early on in his relationship with Angelina that he likes to call L.A. Home. They do, after all, have 3 homes total in the Los Angeles area. More than anywhere else. One in Malibu, one in Los feliz area of Hollywood hills and one just outside of Santa Barbara.
BUT! He has also said, time and time again, since being with Angelina Jolie and having kids and doing his charity work, that he is more fulfilled than he has ever been. That he is happier than he has ever been. That he is living a life he never even dreamed he could live before and that he has a great woman who is a wonderful partner and that he couldn't have asked for a better mother for his children.And yes, he did even refer to her as "superwoman". He also credited her with "saving" the film The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward..." Early screenings had it as a bomb. brad had Angelina watch it and he said, on record, that she took very specific and constructive notes regarding the editing of the film which they then did and next thing you know, when it is released, it is critically well receieved, he wins a Best Actor Award at the Venice Film Festival and Casey Affleck gets an Academy Award Nomination. He credited her with "saving" the film.
Yes, those are the words of a "trapped" man alright!

Posted at 11:05PM on Aug 13th 2008 by Going to California

82. I am readin thru here and mostly I see just individuals posting their
opinions about Jennifer Aniston and some even on the subject of the
break-up of her relationship with John Mayer. Just because alot of
people do not care for Jennifer Aniston does not automatically make
them a Brangelina fan. In fact, most of the posts that allude to Brad
Pitt or Brangelina together are Jennifer Aniston fans and they are
doin a might bit of hatin on Brad and Brangelina...and yet...how are
they in any way related to the break-up of Jennifer Aniston and John
Mayer?? How long are Jennifer Aniston fans going to ride the
Brad-cheated-on-Jen-train-so-therefore-the-state-of-her-life-and-her-unhappiness-singledome-childlessness
et al, is all because of Brad and Brangelina? (BTW Jennifer Aniston DENIES that Brad cheated on her and she HATES being portrayed as a vcitim...if you were her real fan, you'd know that fact and therefore you would not continue to buy into the poor pitiful Jen headlines!!)

When are Jennifer Aniston fans finally going to step up and say SHE made the choice to leave her
marriage to Brad Pitt and has since been unable to find a suitable
spouse and remains childless because she chose to put off having kids
with her then-very-devoted-husband Brad Pitt?? She had from 1998 -
2004 (before he even met Angelina) in which time she could have started
a family with her husband and still maintained her career. Both Lisa
Kudrow and Courteney Cox had children while "Friends" was still in
production. This was Jennifer's choice to say "NO" to kids and kept putting it off

...ya keep saying they (Brangelina) will get their payback...and yet here we go
again...Jennifer Aniston, once again alone, still unmarried, still childless, made 3 films but not a single one yet scheduled to see the light of day (or a movie theatre screen)...
and yet it is STILL Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie's fault.

Okay, you win. They are bad, bad people and they will rot in hell for their sick, twisted evil, sins and mental disorders and their kids will all grow up to be ugly monsters as all 'bastards' are and they will have a dirty, nasty, cheating
split...worse than Charlie Sheen and Denise Richards & Alec Baldwin and Kim Basinger combined!! And
I know, you all so hope that Brad gets only the biological children...I know...I feel ya...cuz that skankalina is so racist and only loves the adopted kids...yeah...gotcha ya...

But until then...ha, ha, ha on Jennifer Aniston...choo, choo, all Jenloonies aboard the Jen Pity Train!!
She is leaving the station YET AGAIN!

I know...you are so happy I'm back...couldn't believe the news when I heard it....LOL!!!

Posted at 11:27PM on Aug 13th 2008 by Make It Right! & Your Ad Here! & Oopsie Daisy again!

83. I think it is wonderful that all you woman have been able to go with only one man and found happiness. Jen was with
Brad 7 years and she got a divorce because he couldn't keep his pants zipped. Angelina has been married twice, dated
or called men to meet her a hotel with she felt the need (she said that on national tv and in a interview) She isn't
married now but has six kids with her live-in. Jen dated Vince a year, Paul a few times and now John in three years.
If Jen stays home she is sad and lonely, if she goes out she is awful and we have to hear all the crap about her ex.
Kate Hudson is the same way. I have friends that are woman and believe me it isn't as simple as just picking one
out and getting married. More and more prefer taking their time. They are just as good as men and whether or
not they want kids is their business. Jen has time. Maybe she just wants to have fun. I am really amazed that women
especially make such a big deal out it. She has been divorced three years and never mentioned Brad. Go Jen.

Posted at 11:36PM on Aug 13th 2008 by Pete

84. Dogs can sense stuff in people way before we can. My dogs have never lied. Every guy my dogs didn't like turned out to be a loser or a user. I used to think John was cool, but now he just seems so full of himself. Save yourself the heartache Jen, and listen to them dawgs!

Posted at 11:40PM on Aug 13th 2008 by peg

85. Perez Hilton has Jennifer Aniston already out and about with Selma Blair's ex Matt Felker...the male model from the 'Toxic' video...

Posted at 12:49AM on Aug 14th 2008 by one stud out...new one in...

86. I believe Jen dumped John. John was counting on getting Jens money. I think Jen finally regained her sence.

Posted at 12:59AM on Aug 14th 2008 by Suz

87. Why don't Jen and John just go on and annouce the break up.

Posted at 1:02AM on Aug 14th 2008 by Chris

88. Well Pete...surprise, surprise...she had one really great guy who worshipped and adored her for 7 years! All he friggin wanted was a family. And that is bad, why? Most women, me being one, complain about men who won't commit and have a family. Brad DID commit and wanted a family and they had to have agreed on this prior to marriage as I believe all people planning to wed discuss having children and then somewhere it changed for Jennifer. And to say she has time? As a man, you say so...and the media may tell you so...as I waited thinking I had more time. Jennifer is 39. At 40, I met the guy who rocked my world and we treid every day, up to 6 times a day for a year and a half and I could not get pregnant! Not even with medical intervention! So no, Pete, she may not have time. You can't guarantee she will have time. I can't gaurantee she will have time. No one can until she tries. If she is counting on it, like I did, she may get a very sorry wake-up call and realize she made the biggest mistake of her life in waiting when she had the love of her life and was happily married for 4 years and had the chance. She was one half of Hollywood's Golden Couple! Or maybe she doesn't want kids at all. That is her right. But then, no one can hold Brad responsible for leaving that marriage when he clearly always said he wanted family...a very large family...from the very beginning. He should have sought an annulment then for fraud if that was the case; that she changed her mind about having kids. If you tell someone you want kids to get married when really you don't know or aren't sure...sounds like a case of atleast misrepresentation to the significant other! People do have a hard time finding the right person so when you do, you shouldn't throw it away, especially over something like a pregnancy might interfere with career plans. Other actresses do it every day. She really could have worked it out if she really wanted to keep her husband. She knew Brad better than anyone and should have known he'd be an excellent hands-on dad if she was worrried about all that responsibility. Look how amazing he has handled 6 kids in under 4 years! Truly a remarkable job he has done.

No one said finding the right guy was easy. But she was married to Brad Pitt, and by most every account, very happily, but then for the last couple of years he kept pressing for kids. Since Oceans Eleven. By Oceans Twelve, they were not hitting the red carpet together. The next year, first week of January, they legally seperated. Now everyone wants to say Brad couldn't keep his pants zipped!

He wanted a family. He got one. And I would put money on the fact that if Agelina said yes tonight to getting married, they'd be married right away. Brad planned his whole wedding to Jennifer. He is a real romantic when it comes to love, marriage and family. Can't blame him for wantin kids...but can blame her if she said she wanted kids and then changed her mind.

Posted at 1:28AM on Aug 14th 2008 by Durden: True Romance

89. I told you that time would bear out all I had to say...all the facts
that I stated...and the predictions...


so far....I'm right on the money...

My opinions are based on FACTS, not GOSSIP...that makes being right an
easy option!!

Posted at 2:28AM on Aug 14th 2008 by Make It Right! & Your Ad Here! & Oopsie Daisy

90. Everybody's 'dogging' on Jen because she's an emotional wreck and overrated . . . put too much of her identity into being 'Mrs. Pitt', was paranoid about the possibility of him cheating on her with co-workers to the point of depriving him of children after making him wait for 4 years, wouldn't admit their marriage was having difficulties, played the victim after she got dumped, keeps trying to 'compete' with Angelina, keeps picking players as boyfriends, thought she was an Oscar-caliber actress when she really doesn't have more depth than Rachel Greene, etc.

Guess we keep posting about her because she's like the train wreck we can't look away from . . . not a sign of popularity . . .

PS I was wondering where all her money came from . . . forgot about the Friends' syndication . . .

Posted at 3:24AM on Aug 14th 2008 by STC

Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments