Celebrity Justice
Ledger's Life Insurance Co: Suicide = No Cash

Heath LedgerThe company that wrote Heath Ledger's $10 million life insurance policy is being sued after claiming the actor's death might have been a suicide, even though officials concluded it was accidental. Lawyers for Ledger's daughter say it's a transparent ploy to avoid paying the money.

ReliaStar Life Insurance Company wrote the policy in June 2007 -- six months before Ledger died. The beneficiary of the policy is a trustee who would hold the money for 2-year-old Matilda.

Instead of paying the $10 mil, ReliaStar set out to investigate whether Ledger took his own life, despite the fact that the New York City Medical Examiner ruled the death accidental.

TMZ has obtained a lawsuit, filed by Matilda's trustee, claiming ReliaStar (owned by ING Americas) has acted in bad faith by not promptly paying the $10 million and by wrongfully prying into the life of Heath Ledger after his death.

Sources say lawyers for the insurance company have claimed Ledger's death was "suspicious" -- possibly suicide, which would nullify the policy. The company alleges in its answer to the lawsuit, "ReliaStar is entitled to investigate Plaintiff's claim to determine if the 'Suicide' provision is applicable." That provision states, "If the Insured commits suicide ... we will pay only the amount of premiums paid to us."

ReliaStar's lawyers have informed Matilda's lawyers they intend to take the depositions of Mary-Kate Olsen, as well as the masseuse who was at Ledger's home when he died, Ledger's colleagues on his last film, his agents, doctors, psychologists and others. Lawyers for Matilda believe the insurance company is trying to scare and shame them into submission. They believe ReliaStar is trying to drag the process out, for what could be years, to avoid paying the money.

We're also told ReliaStar believes Ledger may have lied on two questions on his insurance application -- specifically, whether he was taking prescription drugs when he filled out the application and whether he ever used illegal drugs.

In its answer to the lawsuit, ReliaStar claims it can contest the policy if Ledger lied on the application and it was a "material misrepresentation." Sources tell us Ledger had a prescription for Ambien when he filled out the application, but Ambien was not in his system when he died, nor were any illegal drugs.

Lawyers for Matilda's trust claim ReliaStar is flagrantly violating California law, which prohibits insurance companies from re-examining insurance applications after the policyholder dies. In the lawsuit, Matilda's lawyers say they received a letter from ReliaStar, asking them to identify "all physicians who attended to [Ledger] and all hospitals or institutions where [he] was treated since 1996." Matilda's lawyers say the request blatantly violates the law.

An official for ReliaStar told TMZ, "No decision has been made on the claim." But lawyers for Matilda's trust believe ReliaStar should have already paid and, according to the suit, is acting "maliciously, fraudulently and/or oppressively ... depriving plaintiff of the insurance policy benefits."

Filed under: Celebrity Justice, Heath Ledger

Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 5)Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

16. The insurance company is never going to pay a dime if he lied on the application stating that he was not on any rx drugs. 1 lie and you are screwed.

Posted at 9:34AM on Sep 29th 2008 by madge

17. Where is Danny Glover (the Rainmaker) when you need him?

Posted at 9:41AM on Sep 29th 2008 by Curious

18. I think the insurance companies suck and don't care about anyone. They actually hire people to disprove claims so they don't have to payout. I hope no bails there ass out. Angela

Posted at 9:43AM on Sep 29th 2008 by angela

19. Why would they insure a heavy drug user? Sounds like the insurance company planned to use this streategy all along if he overdosed.

Posted at 10:28AM on Sep 29th 2008 by Kay

20. If its under California law then punitive damages are allowed for bad faith. The damages would be based on the worth of the company, so in theory could be 10 or even 100 times the amount in question. A good insurance lawyer like Shernoff, Bidaret and darras will take care of this quickly, probably settle for 50 million.

Posted at 10:32AM on Sep 29th 2008 by JJ

21. To everyone that jumped all over poor Mary-Kate -- THIS IS WHY she did NOT want to talk!! Anyone with a brain knew that she didn't want to say something that could screw this up and we ALL know who greedy insurance companies try to twist words to get the result THEY want to hear!!

Posted at 10:33AM on Sep 29th 2008 by TOLDYA

22. Insurance companies are scam artist.
They are quick to take your money, but when its time for them to pay a claim they make up any excuse not to pay.
I hate insurance companies, they all need to go down like Merrill Lynch did.
Give Heath what he deserved you pieces of garbage!

Posted at 11:44AM on Sep 29th 2008 by Not Suprised

23. in most states insurance companies will pay even if the cause of death is suicide as long as the policy has been in effect for one or two years.

Posted at 11:54AM on Sep 29th 2008 by mittelfrueh

24. Remember this bogus ReliaStar insurance company. They don't pay claims. Even they know it's not suicide, may they get out of insurance after this is done.

Posted at 12:21PM on Sep 29th 2008 by jockflip

25. No way would the insurance company write a 10Million policy to someone who takes several prescription drugs that can kill within a 24 hour period without writing all kinds of exclusions in the policy. The insurance company has every right to examine the cause of death of such a young person who said they were healthy and "didn't take" prescription drugs. It doesn't matter that the medical examiner listed the death as accidental. If Ledger listed what all he takes on the insurance application the insurance company would have requested medical records from the doctors to find why he was taking these drugs before writing such a large policy and would have written in exclusions to the policy.

Posted at 12:35PM on Sep 29th 2008 by Dee

26. F987&*(#&%*(ing Insurance Companies. They don't want to pay - because they probably don't have the capital to pay it out. No insurance or bank company now-a-days has the money. So, they are making all of these stale claims to delay. What a shame>!!!!!!

Posted at 1:10PM on Sep 29th 2008 by Sean

27. Is TMZ trying to be funny by placing an icon saying "click here to talk live" under the keith Ledger Story. After all he is dead. If so that senseless not funny.

Posted at 1:19PM on Sep 29th 2008 by 00 Diva

28. RE: #28- You're kidding, right? And BTW it's Heath, not Keith. And yes, he is dead and if you think the link is to chat live with Heath, then go ahead and give it a try. The rest of us will chat about the INSURANCE company topics discussed in the article.

Posted at 1:33PM on Sep 29th 2008 by Lauren

29. is the 19 mill a double pay for accidental death ? what was policy written for 5 or 10 most pay 2 X for accidental if so they have a right to investigate & the Olson got off kind of easy in court now that big $ is involved lets see. drug dealers get time for dealing in a situation like this yes ? he is part to blame for combining , so is his doctors who wrote meds knowing history etc & the Olson if she gave or got him stuff ......

Posted at 1:41PM on Sep 29th 2008 by mike

30. Since insurance companies basically regulate themselves (or have no regulation whatsoever), I doubt that they will ever be held accountable. However, I think that in cases where they fight paying out and end up having to pay, they should have to pay interest, the other party's legal fees, and cpmpensation for any duress caused to the beneficiary. JMO. Never will happen, though.

Posted at 1:42PM on Sep 29th 2008 by QE2

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry.
Inappropriate or purely promotional comments may be removed. E-mail addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Your e-mail address is what makes your comments unique, not your user name. To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or e-mail address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to three URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted -- no need to use <p> or <br> tags.

Do you want us to remember your personal information for next time?
What this means: We place a cookie on your computer that stores your e-mail address and the non-unique name you have selected. Next time, these comment form fields will be automatically populated with your information. It saves you a couple of steps so you can quickly express your thoughts on the latest TMZ story.

Hot Tips