Celebrity Justice
Witnesses Say Gerard Was Provoked

So we just told you the LAPD is investigating whether Gerard Butler kicked a paparazzi's ass yesterday. Well, there's more to this story.
Gerard Butler
Sources tell us witnesses have now come forward with a very different account. They are saying the papper was tailing Gerard for hours. And, they say, the photog was driving "recklessly" as he "chased" Butler's limo, almost hitting several pedestrians. The photog says he endangered no one.

The witnesses say after Gerard allegedly got out of the limo and struck the photog in the face, the photog continued following Butler for more than an hour before going to the hospital. But the agency the photog works for says Gerard struck the dude at 1:45 AM and he was at the cop shop at 2:10 AM.

And, we're told, the photog spoke with a civil lawyer before contacting cops.

Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 8) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

16. PEPPER SPRAY is the answer or should help a lot. Shower those paps/stalkers with PEPPER SPRAY - they will back off and there are no charges for breaking equipment or medical bills. PEPPER SPRAY the hell out of them. I hate those stalkers.

Posted at 3:11PM on Oct 8th 2008 by Ms_Tell_It_Like_It_Is

17. Do ya think Butler was yelling "this is Sparta!!" as he punched the pap? LOL

Posted at 5:08PM on Oct 8th 2008 by lil wayne

18. Great. The lousy pap is going to hit paydirt in the court system, and Gerard will be forced to settle. I love the idea of MACE. Why don't all cebrities carry mace and blast the paps in the face when they get too close? Serve them right.

Posted at 3:16PM on Oct 8th 2008 by Too damn funny

19. Just one of those rare moments I pray to God the celebrity walks...

Posted at 3:17PM on Oct 8th 2008 by PEPPER SPRAY!!! Yeh, I like that...

20. Violence is never the answer Gerard. We're not savages, well guess you are. Should have just ignored him and went home on your merry drunk talentless hack way. If you can't take the paparazzi heat stay out of LA.

Posted at 3:18PM on Oct 8th 2008 by T-in-SD

21. #19, T-in-SD,

read before you post, retard...

Posted at 3:28PM on Oct 8th 2008 by grow a brain retard

22. This wimpy pap looks like a b!tch-made fa66ot and deserved whatever a$$-kicking he received.

Posted at 3:32PM on Oct 8th 2008 by Toby Christensen

23. Your guys are retarded...if you knew how much paps got paid you'd all be doing it too. Gerards side of the story is total bull...he has a history of drunken brawls and fights with paps.

Posted at 11:55AM on Oct 10th 2008 by SIlvio

24. The Pap got what he deserved !!!!!!!!!! i would have shot him but that's just me!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 3:36PM on Oct 8th 2008 by Divashels

25. So, finally, the rest of the story...
I think the paps do this kind of thing on purpose to egg on the celebs till they will break so they can sue them for a lot of money. They'll suck 'em dry one way or another. Don't they know Gerry used to be a lawyer??

Posted at 3:50PM on Oct 8th 2008 by getthepaps

26. I think Gerard should've kicked his ass. The pap has to be the most annoying thing for celebrities. Good going Gerard baby, defend your right to privacy.

Posted at 3:52PM on Oct 8th 2008 by if only for one night with gerard butler

27. hey #19 if it is true the razzi was driving like an idiot would it be better if Gerry kept on his merry way and took the chance of someone being killed by the bonehead? Gerry is not a savage, he is a talented good hearted man. I hope and pray that he gets out of this, because he was doing a service to the public.

Posted at 3:51PM on Oct 8th 2008 by Just me

28. Violence still is never the answer Gerard, I mean retard. If you're having problems with a pap, call the cops. Vigilantism, is also not the answer. Hope that pap makes bank and the book gets thrown at Gerard. Oh and yeah its thanks to the paps once again that this site is here and that we're all on it. So think before you write retard. And if you don't like seeing pap stories, don't read TMZ.

Posted at 3:58PM on Oct 8th 2008 by T-in-SD

29. Gerard Butler is insanely, ridiculously gorgeous!!! I would follow him anywhere!!

Posted at 3:58PM on Oct 8th 2008 by tickles

30. Grow up all of you. Especially Gerard. Cops are there to protect and serve. Gerards big head is even bigger than I thought if he resorts to beating up people. That savage.

Posted at 4:05PM on Oct 8th 2008 by T-in-SD

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments