Who'd you rather?
The Montag Sisters: Good vs. Evil

Do you like your Montag with or without plastic?
Holly and Heidi Montag
Now that Holly Montag (Heidi's older sis) has officially moved to L.A., we're wondering ...



Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 2) Previous 15 Comments

16. Who's the third choice?

They're both UGLY!!

Heidi makes Tori Spelling look like a beauty queen.

Posted at 2:57PM on Nov 6th 2008 by The Montag sisters parents

17. You people are crazy. I woudl love to nail heidi from behind . Shes got a cute little dumper

Posted at 3:16PM on Nov 6th 2008 by Shugity

18. Wow! I didn't know Heidi even had a sister. She's cute!!

Posted at 3:38PM on Nov 6th 2008 by miley$$$

19. 5. It's "accept" not "except". Except means I like everyone except Heidi, as in the exception to the rule. Learn it and be literate.

Posted at 1:04PM on Nov 6th 2008 by AA

Yes AA I do know the difference between the two, I made a mistake and will admit to that. Thanks for the correction, I didn't even notice.

I'm only guessing but were you offened by my plastic surgery comment???

-probably a candidate... lol.

Posted at 3:54PM on Nov 6th 2008 by Novalee

20. Before Heidi gets anymore surgery she should chop half her chin and forehead off. Is it just me or does she have a huge long head??? (lol)

Posted at 4:07PM on Nov 6th 2008 by Katie

21. These two are useless!! Dig a hole in the desert and bury them....................please!

Posted at 6:00PM on Nov 6th 2008 by tooty

22. At least her sister Holly looks like a girl...Heidi looks like a transvestite!

Posted at 8:39PM on Nov 6th 2008 by MissMiss

23. Heidi is barely recognizable from what shelooked like in season 1. It's a shame because she was prettier back then. She looks like she has lost all her idenity and traits. She looks like a (fake) blonde stick with a tiny beak and baseball boobs.

I'll blame it on Spencer.

Posted at 9:22PM on Nov 6th 2008 by heather

24. One's normal (Holly) and one is totally plastic & phony (Heidi). Heidi can go to hell; I'll take Holly...

Posted at 9:59PM on Nov 6th 2008 by NY121

25. Heidi looks like one of the trannies that hang out down on Melrose blvd...I mean, uh..that's where I've heard they hang out....

Posted at 10:30PM on Nov 6th 2008 by Fernando Valenzuela

26. I LOVE HEIDI !!!

SHE VOTED 4 MCCAIN

BUT HOLLY IS HOTTER

IS SHE SPOKEN 4 ??? !!!!

I LIKE 2 SEE HER IN MAXIM !!!!


BTW, NICKY HILTON IS HOTTER THAN PARIS !!!

Posted at 9:54AM on Nov 7th 2008 by lowell

27. heidi is fugly.
she has the body of a 12 yr old BOY
except with fake boobs.
holly is waaay cuter and i hope she doesn't change.

Posted at 1:48PM on Nov 8th 2008 by ohpoopy

Previous 15 Comments