Celebrity Justice
Dixie Chick Maines Sued for Loud Mouth

Dixie Chick Natalie Maines can't keep her mouth shut about a trio of murders in 1993 -- and now she's being hauled into court for allegedly placing the rap on a guy whose stepson was one of the victims.

The inveterate Bush-basher -- and her bandmates -- has been sued in Arkansas by Terry Hobbs, whose then-8-year-old stepson Steve Branch was killed back in 1993 along with two other boys. But, as reports say, Maines is singled out in court papers.

Hobbs has never been charged or implicated in the murders -- three other men were convicted -- but Maines has been outspoken in her belief Hobbs was involved.

Hobbs says in the suit he's lost income and reputation, and that Maines' claims are "so extreme in degree as to be ... atrocious and utterly intolerable." The band couldn't be reached for comment.

Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 6) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

31. this is what happends when drunk men kill there wives like mark byers did and then gets too close to farm animals!!!

Posted at 4:35PM on Dec 5th 2008 by FREE THE WEST MEMPHIS THREE

32. Yea, TMZ you should have mentioned the case and the www.wm3.org site. But I must admit when I heard she was getting sued I was certain it was Eric the Midget from Howard Stern doing it. He must be creaming in his granimals as we speak!!

Posted at 11:22AM on Dec 5th 2008 by hannah

33. It's all about the money. If she wasn't a celeb this wouldn't be an issue. If average Joe was squawking around town about this nothing would come of it. Greed, pure and simple. Heck the political parties were slandering each other back and forth - did anyone sue? Money honey $$$$.

Posted at 11:22AM on Dec 5th 2008 by katie

34. either you guys are retarded or are not getting the big picture.

if this actually goes to court its great. he is sueing her for saying he had something to do with the murder. he has to be able to prove that she is lieing on that.

this could backfire on him if he actually had something to do with the murders.

Posted at 12:54PM on Dec 5th 2008 by waggy

35. Put her away. She most obviously needs some jail time worse than millions of others. Might teach he a lesson in civics. Something she lacks completely.

Posted at 3:10PM on Dec 5th 2008 by Jake

36. Last time I checked, Natalie Maines was not a police detective, a lawyer, the judge, or on the jury for this case. Therefore, she has no access to details or evidence. She is just another uninformed Hollywood celebrity talking about things that she has no business discussing. Let's stop listening to these people and leave upholding the law to the trained professionals, not an "entertainer".

Posted at 10:53AM on Dec 9th 2008 by JK

37. This case is so sad... three boys were imprisoned for the murders and have been forced to become men while behind bars. TMZ--- show a little journalistic integrity and tell their story! After hearing the facts, it is so hard to believe that the case was proven "beyond a reasonable doubt". Hate Maines for her politics if you must but she is TOTALLY RIGHT to be fighting this battle publicly! If more people would, maybe the truth would come out!

Posted at 12:05PM on Dec 5th 2008 by Becky Schoewe

38. I think she got the wrong person, I think John Mark Byers is the real killer.

Badfish

Posted at 2:22PM on Dec 5th 2008 by Badfish

39. I cannot believe she has the stones to crawl out of her hole and attract attention to herself at all! Does she not realize that one of the few things that unite the people of this country is hatred of her?! It is so painfully clear everytime she opens her mouth how ignorant and uneducated she is. I hope he bankrupts her and no one in America will hire to mop floors. What a Skank!!

Posted at 12:18PM on Dec 5th 2008 by Mackenzie

40. Do you all even know why you hate her so much? Because she said she was embarrased that GW was from Texas? She said years ago what everyone thinks now. GW Bush IS an embarrasment to this country, will go down as the WORST president in history. Took us to war over FALSE pretenses. HE should be tried of crimes for what he has done. Now why were you mad at her again? She is standing up for people who don't have a voice, because like her music or not, she has a voice. At least she's doing something.

Posted at 1:50PM on Dec 5th 2008 by CaboRedneck

41. For all you people still saying she hates America - huh, guess who turned out to be right about Bush and our illegal invasion of Iraq? Those of us speaking who had to backbone to stand up to and speak up against and question the Bush Administration never had any trouble sleeping and, oh,look, WE WERE RIGHT! And I said the same thing she did about two months before here, when I was in Australia - ooooh, ban me from the radio too.

Secondly, who's to say Hobbs wasn't involved? Jennifer Hudson's idiot sister still claims her ex wasn't the killer - and yet there he is, arrested and all. I still wonder if she was involved as well. And we all know OJ did it and yet he got away with it.

Third, I'm sure she isn't the only one questioning his innocence so why isn't he suing everyone that is questioning? Or is it simply he's a Bush supporter who wants to follow his leaders example and get money any way he can - ethical or not.

Posted at 12:24PM on Dec 5th 2008 by AQ

42. I don't like her, but in this case she is absolutely correct in voicing her opinion! There are 3 innocent people in jail because of ignorance and utter stupidity! NO, he should NOT get a penny!! Please, people - don't just say something because you don't like her. I can't stand her, but I don't want a guilty child murderer to become a millionaire and hopefully all the national attention will shed some light on this case and put him in jail where he belongs!!

Posted at 5:18PM on Dec 7th 2008 by MainesIsCorrect

43. Oh dear Lord AQ... eight years of Bush bashing is quite enough already. If you're that upset about Ms. Maines being attacked for her beliefs and believe in what she is saying, then get involved. Don't sit around in your jammies spewing more hatred on the internet. Can we all just move on from this and work together to solve issues that are fixable instead of rehashing history. It's angry bitter people like you that hang onto wrongs of the past that keep this Country in turmoil.

Posted at 12:31PM on Dec 5th 2008 by MsBitter

44. FREE THE WM3. now.

Posted at 12:35PM on Dec 5th 2008 by bree

45. The three "men" convicted were young boys in 1993 and are innocent. Maines is doing a service by bringing light to this terrible injustice. Henry Rollins also advocates for these young men. I wish more people would speak out about the West Memphis Three!

Posted at 6:12PM on Dec 5th 2008 by bullseye

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments