"American Idol" Reality Check

Our "American Idol" spies tell us Season 8 is going to look more like "Big Brother" than a true singing competition.

We're told producers have decided to show how the contestants interact with each other off the stage. They will show a lot more "behind the scenes" than ever before. But here's the problem -- the show is a cash cow and they've already taken time out of the singing competition for more commercials. Now they're going to take even more time out for the whole "bitch-you-stole-my-blouse" thing.

And we're now told firmly the new, fourth judge is not there to replace Paula. Producers think four is the magic number. The downside -- when one or two judges tell contestants they suck, is it overkill to hear it from four?

And no "Idol Gives Back" this coming season. After all, they gotta pay Simon ...



Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 3) Previous 15 Comments

31. This show really needs to come to an end.

Posted at 6:16PM on Dec 12th 2008 by J

32. this is the formula. on x factor they promoted a berd for simon and then brought in a your woman to make sharon osborne have a cat fighting fit. i guess it's paula' turn now. i will not watch women act in this manner over an obviously gay man or anything else. this is all drama and the talent has declined. it's time for a real talent form idol or go home.

Posted at 1:48PM on Dec 13th 2008 by annan emous

33. Good, maybe this will be the last of it, finally!! Idol Gives back was the only god things about this show anymore. I hope someone wrote down who's lousy ideas THAT was. Pack your bags...

Posted at 4:02PM on Dec 13th 2008 by Robin

34. #13...

I read somewhere that if there is a tie between the judges, Simon has final say.

Posted at 10:32PM on Dec 18th 2008 by PinkPunkPrincess

35. Idol Gives Back is not happening because the producers never intended for it to be an annual event. In fact, shortly after Season 7 ended, the producers announced that Idol Gives Back would most likely take a break for Season 8. It will most likely return in Season 9. So, it has nothing to do with the bad economy or Scroogelike attitudes. The season hasn't even started, and already, things are being sensationalized.

Posted at 9:44AM on Dec 30th 2008 by Barnsinger

Previous 15 Comments