New "Idol" Judge Catches McPheever

1. not even close!!!

Posted at 3:59AM on Jan 15th 2009 by 99centz

2. Hey 99! There you are!

Posted at 4:38AM on Jan 15th 2009 by maggie

3. Id eat both of them

Posted at 7:00AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Ron

4. funny thing is mcphee's daddy/husband is older than kara.mcphee is so phony.

Posted at 7:15AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Roger

5. We have seen that Katharine McPhee can't sing, she can't act either so maybe its time for her to be a porn star

Posted at 7:29AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Raymond

6. McPhee can't sing? you must be deaf. Probably one of the best from crappy idol singers

Posted at 8:08AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Idolfan

7. I was thinking the same exact thing when I was watching the show. I thought she kinda looked like a cross between Katharine McPhee and Demi Moore.

Posted at 8:16AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Jess 1

8. Your dead on right there Raymond. Porn would be a good place for Mcphee to use her boob job to her ability

Posted at 8:40AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Patricia

9. i'd bang em both !!!!

they look like a mother/daughter combo !!!!!!



mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm



yummmy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 9:39AM on Jan 15th 2009 by lowell

10. I wouldnt brag if I were Kara about writing any songs on Mcphees debut album since it was a flop. Katharine is a joke always has been.

Posted at 9:41AM on Jan 15th 2009 by kim

11. Roger+Raymond=Patricia.So blatantly obvious is your new ploy!
Did you think we'd not notice that you have finally had a nervous breakdown and have now become the Three Faces of Eve?
Now you write comments under ASSumed names and then agree with them?
Once again,Patricia....you have clearly demonstrated how sick an individual you are!Get a life and some help!

Posted at 10:42AM on Jan 15th 2009 by keefir1

12. #5- I totally agree. That would be nice to see both of these hot babes in a porno. I would def do them both.

Posted at 9:59AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Hmmmm

13. I see why they chose her, but my wife and I were just saying that she is the love child of:

Geena Davis (Top of face) and Donny Osmond (Bottom of face)

Posted at 6:05PM on Jan 15th 2009 by Shawn 24

14. Am I the only one who doesn't even know who this Kara person is?

Posted at 11:23AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Danielle

15. danielle - kara is the new AI judge. annoying as anything, and she talks to the guy contestants like she wants to get it on with them...and she acts like she is jealous of young pretty girls. lol, can you tell i'm not a fan??

Posted at 11:39AM on Jan 15th 2009 by What, Bitches??