TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

New "Idol" Judge Catches McPheever

1/15/2009 5:30 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF

Here's new "American Idol" judge Kara DioGuardi (left) -- and Season 5 "Idol" wannabeen Katharine McPhee (right).

Kara and Kat

One of them wrote six songs on McPhee's debut album.

We're just sayin.'


27 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

99centz    

not even close!!!

2075 days ago
2.

maggie    

Hey 99! There you are!

2075 days ago
3.

pamela    

funny thing is mcphee's daddy/husband is older than kara.mcphee is so phony.

2074 days ago
4.

pamela    

We have seen that Katharine McPhee can't sing, she can't act either so maybe its time for her to be a porn star

2074 days ago
5.

Jess 1    

I was thinking the same exact thing when I was watching the show. I thought she kinda looked like a cross between Katharine McPhee and Demi Moore.

2074 days ago
6.

pamela    

Your dead on right there Raymond. Porn would be a good place for Mcphee to use her boob job to her ability

2074 days ago
7.

lowell    

i'd bang em both !!!!

they look like a mother/daughter combo !!!!!!



mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm



yummmy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2074 days ago
8.

kim    

I wouldnt brag if I were Kara about writing any songs on Mcphees debut album since it was a flop. Katharine is a joke always has been.

2074 days ago
9.

keefir1    

Roger+Raymond=Patricia.So blatantly obvious is your new ploy!
Did you think we'd not notice that you have finally had a nervous breakdown and have now become the Three Faces of Eve?
Now you write comments under ASSumed names and then agree with them?
Once again,Patricia....you have clearly demonstrated how sick an individual you are!Get a life and some help!

2074 days ago
10.

Very Interesting    

#5- I totally agree. That would be nice to see both of these hot babes in a porno. I would def do them both.

2074 days ago
11.

Shawn 24    

I see why they chose her, but my wife and I were just saying that she is the love child of:

Geena Davis (Top of face) and Donny Osmond (Bottom of face)

2074 days ago
12.

Danielle    

Am I the only one who doesn't even know who this Kara person is?

2074 days ago
13.

anthonysdreamgirl**    

danielle - kara is the new AI judge. annoying as anything, and she talks to the guy contestants like she wants to get it on with them...and she acts like she is jealous of young pretty girls. lol, can you tell i'm not a fan??

2074 days ago
14.

Chevy Girl    

I like Kara. I think she's going to be a great additon to AI. Give her a chance.

2074 days ago
15.

Pittsburgh Storm    

Kara looks like a brunette Kim from Atlanta Housewives...with a better singing voice, of course.

2074 days ago
| 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web