New "Idol" Judge Catches McPheever

16. I like Kara. I think she's going to be a great additon to AI. Give her a chance.

Posted at 11:53AM on Jan 15th 2009 by Chevy Girl

17. Kara looks like a brunette Kim from Atlanta Housewives...with a better singing voice, of course.

Posted at 12:25PM on Jan 15th 2009 by Pittsburgh Storm

18. Katharine is a lot prettier than Kara. Katharine is the prettiest girl in the world.

Posted at 12:18PM on Jan 15th 2009 by Bigkatfan

19. WHO THE HELL IS KARA DIOGUARDI?!
I'VE NEVER HEARD OF HER IN MY LIFE, BUT YET SHE THINKS SHE'S THE S**T ON AMERICAN IDOL.
That Bikini chick might have not been the best, but she sure was better than her in the MODESTY department.
How low do you have to stoop to try and PRETEND like someone knows who you are???
I hate Kara, it was genious to add her onto the show...it is someone I would watch so I can love to hate her even more.

Posted at 12:28PM on Jan 15th 2009 by SimoneOG2009

20. she's pretty and she's a talented, respected songwriter. i think she's a great addition to the show.

Posted at 1:37PM on Jan 15th 2009 by lena

21. kara writes crap songs for crap performers who don't know the difference between crap and real music. she thinks she's all that but real musicians would just laugh in her face. trust me.

Posted at 2:51PM on Jan 15th 2009 by ommo

22. Kara needs to stop using the word "chops"... Frankly, I don't care much for her... McPhee should be a judge though...

Posted at 3:02PM on Jan 15th 2009 by phdguru

23. I'm sick of the "Chops" thing too..I'd slam Kat into next week before Kara...no question

Posted at 4:20PM on Jan 15th 2009 by MGMLV

24. KAT IS UGLY. KARA LOOKS BETTER

Posted at 4:31PM on Jan 15th 2009 by butter

25. Katherine McPhee has always reminded me of Katie Holmes, Tom Cruise's wife! Especially when her hair was long.

Posted at 9:13PM on Jan 15th 2009 by LoriIowa

26. Kat and Kara do remind me of each other in the way they look, but not when they're posing. Katharine is amazingly beautiful. I like Kara, and I think she's pretty too. Kat is so amazing and she has a new album with David Foster coming out. And for everyone who says mean things, you should think about what you would feel like if someone said those things about you, even if you didn't know who they were. I bet you wouldn't say these things directly to them, so why do you let the internet change you? hopefully neither of them see the hateful comments on here.

Posted at 8:38PM on Jan 15th 2009 by OhGeez

27. she also wrote songs for Pink and Gwen Stefani, Kelly Clarkson, Celine Dion....just sayin

Posted at 9:06AM on Jan 16th 2009 by Jeana