'A.I.' Judges Issue Contempt Citation

16. They were looking at her like that because she went out of turn!!!! The producers have F'd up the format of the show so much, she thought they were switching who starts the comments like they had done in the past. If you were paying attention you would have noticed that they went back to the old old format of Randy starting everytime. Give her a break....she has some decent, knowledgable things to say, she doesn't have to hire a writer like Paula did to keep up and she doesn't act like a friggin fifth grader
like Paula and Simon. I'm so over those two. They should replace ALL of the judges each year. I'm over the old trio.

Posted at 9:11AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Sam

17. Could it have been an honest mistake-maybe she thought it was her turn to go first?? Or not...maybe I'm just feeling overly generous this morning...
All that aside-I think it's clear, she isn't a favorite of Simon-noticed the finger thing too...tee hee...
Three judges is enuf-don't know why they added another one-

Posted at 9:14AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by luvsimon

18. I think Kara thought she was suppose to speak first. They were rotating who would speak first and I liked it better that way. I think it's only fair that they rotate as for years Randy has always been first. I'm not too fond of Kara either but Paula makes me sick with all her ranting and it's seems very difficult for her to get out what she's trying to say. She also makes me sick as to how she talks about Simon when she's on other shows and then snuggles up to him like he's her lover (which I think she wants). I heard that Paula's contract is up this year and also this might be the last year that Simon is on the show. If Simon goes, so do I.

Posted at 9:23AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Madelyn

19. Send her home. I dont like her. She seems stuck up. Paula Rocks!!!!!

Posted at 9:20AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Andrea

20. Oh get a grip TMZ and all you Kara bashers. The judges were only determining whose turn it was to talk first. And Simon was NOT flipping the bird. He scratches his face like that ALL the time.

Posted at 9:21AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Pacer

21. It WAS her turn to speak first. Randy spoke first on the previous performer.

Posted at 9:23AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by unknown

22. As much as I dislike this Kara person, the singer who just finished was the second one to perform last night, and generally the judges rotate who evaluates the contestant first, meaning the second judge (Kara) would have started off on the second contestant. But I can see why the other three get so easily annoyed with her.

Posted at 9:29AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Reverend Ramona

23. American idol is fake!! (also dancing with the stars).. They already know whos gonna win from the beginning. Check out TWIT tv.. watch the podcast about it.

Posted at 9:29AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by emilee

24. BETWEEN KARA AND PAULA THE MEN CAN'T GET A WORD IN. AND THEY ARE THE REASON THE SHOW RUNS OVER EVERY WEEK.

Posted at 9:48AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by PENNY

25. American Idol is fake! I dont know why people even watch this show.. (same with dancing with the stars) Check out TWIT tv .. they talk about how fake it is

Posted at 9:31AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by emilee

26. Randy and Simon were thinking what the world was thinking; "Kara is
such a tool! Why is she even on here?" She ruined the dynamics of the
show and between the three judges. "IF" Simon leaves the show, it
will be, at least in part, because of Kara. Her judgment sucks, she
has the personality of a 'wet blanket' and before (and after the
show), she's a wanna-be-famous nobody. I personally stopped watching
A.I. a few years ago back because (and after) I saw that; great
singers (example: Jennifer Hudson) were being voted off in place of mediocre
singers, too much focus on bad singers during the audition phase of
the show, bad singers (example; Sanjaia and William Hung) were being
praised and kept towards the top strictly to be 'made fun of by the
public' and simply because the show had become boring and
predictable. I give A.I., at most, 2 more seasons and it will be cancelled.

Posted at 9:33AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Anonymous

27. OMG did you see SImon at the end giving her the finger LMFAO priceless!

Posted at 9:34AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by LMAO

28. Randy and Simon were thinking what the world was thinking; "Kara is
such a tool! Why is she even on here?" She ruined the dynamics of the
show and between the three judges. "IF" Simon leaves the show, it
will be, at least in part, because of Kara. Her judgment sucks, she
has the personality of a 'wet blanket' and before (and after the
show), she's a 'wanna-be-famous' nobody. I personally stopped watching
A.I. a few years ago back because (and after) I saw that; great
singers (example: Jennifer Hudson) were being voted off in place of
mediocre singers, too much focus on bad singers during the audition phase of
the show, bad singers (example; Sanjaia and William Hung) were being
praised and kept towards the top strictly to be 'made fun of by the
public' and simply because the show had become boring and
predictable. I give A.I., at most, 2 more seasons and it will be
canceled.

Posted at 9:45AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Anonymous

29. UGH! I want to kick her in the TEETH! She is SO annoying.

Posted at 9:40AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by beejo

30. Simon most definitely gave her the finger and thought no one would notice. Usually when you rub your face, you use your pointer finger next to the thumb, not your middle finger.

As far as Kara, just shut up and go home, lady.

At the beginning, Randy touched her arm and said, "me" and looked at Simon. Simon gave a gesture like, "Let it go," and then flipper her the finger after her "brilliant" comments.

This season bores me. Totally bores me. None of these people...even that icky Lambert...should be the Idol. They should all be working karaoke bars in some small town. And if Lambert wins, you can just call him Taylor Hicks six months after that.

Posted at 9:44AM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Me