Beyonce's Dad Was Right -- Hoax, Hoax, Hoax!!!

46. Totally disappointed. Either way I still don't care for Beyonce, nor her funky, jerk-like motions she calls dancing!! I bet that really was her "singing" TMZ just doesnt want to deal with "her people" What a shame!!

Posted at 5:09PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by I'm That Girl

47. I don't think anyone in their right mind could believe for one second that that tape was for real. I mean, seariously? Are there really people out there who listened to that and honestly would say they couldn't hear the messing around someone did with it? God bless you, if you did, becuase you'd be one clueless fool who deserves to be thought of as a great big dumbass. I mean, really...

Posted at 5:13PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by donbear

48. God people are so ridiculous. Maybe you dont like her but how can you actually say she sucks?
She has a lot of vocal talent, and she actually does write a large amount of her songs.
People talk bad about her for the songs she didnt write when really she writes more of her own stuff than the majority of stars these days.

Posted at 5:26PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Hahahaha

49. And all of the people who believe that dumb rumor about her being 33 or whatever? you're pathetic.
And the people who call her a media whore? she's rarely in the news? wtf.
Jeeze, Im not even a big beyonce fan but you people are unbelievable.

Posted at 5:27PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Hahahaha

50. BEYONCE WILL BE KNOWN AS THE LIP SYNC DIVA AND HOW TECHNOLOGY RUINED AN INDUSTRY. SHE WILL BE THE HEADLINER OF CBS MYSTERY - 48HR PRESENTS.

Posted at 5:26PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by 3 hot chics & 1 pimpin gangsta

51. Who cares?.The bitch is ashamed of her race to begin with.Any black woman that goes for white women flowing blonde hair is a traitor to her race.Beyonce looks more like a white woman that a black woman.Black people want to be proud of their race but the black women turn their back on their race by trying to look like white women more and more.I laugh everytime I see one of these undefined bitches.Neither black nor white but neutral.He,he,he.....

Posted at 5:40PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Oscar

52. If she really could sing... her father wouldn't have bothered writing TMZ... what was he afraid of? people investigating his fat-arsed daughter's voice a little more closely... scrutinizin' the Bison?
If she's such a great singer... why was he so threateded... ASK YOURSELVES THAT... then get back to me.

Posted at 5:51PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Craig Listeria\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

53. 52. Who cares?.The bitch is ashamed of her race to begin with.Any black woman that goes for white women flowing blonde hair is a traitor to her race.Beyonce looks more like a white woman that a black woman.Black people want to be proud of their race but the black women turn their back on their race by trying to look like white women more and more.I laugh everytime I see one of these undefined bitches.Neither black nor white but neutral.He,he,he.....

Posted at 5:40PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Oscar

Oscar, I applaud Black women for trying to look White... you know what they say...Once you go White...you look outta sight!

Posted at 5:54PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Craig Listeria\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\

54. Sure is a lot of hate on someone who ran after and fulfilled a dream...I like Beyonce so whatev- The haters on here sound like my sorry students that sit in class all day doing jack and complain, mock and tease my hard-working smart kids.

Posted at 6:04PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Truth Hurts

55. Beyonce does have singing talent and don't believe for one second that the recording of her horrible voice is a fake. Beyonce cannot sing.

Posted at 4:46AM on Apr 23rd 2009 by Karma is a bitch

56. RE: 52. Who cares?.The bitch is ashamed of her race to begin with.Any black woman that goes for white women flowing blonde hair is a traitor to her race.Beyonce looks more like a white woman that a black woman.Black people want to be proud of their race but the black women turn their back on their race by trying to look like white women more and more.I laugh everytime I see one of these undefined bitches.Neither black nor white but neutral.He,he,he.....

Posted at 5:40PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Oscar

hey dont you f'n dare say shes white!! we aint claiming that horse faced heffer...lets say shes iranian...everybody hates iran!!!...lol

Posted at 6:53PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by seymore butts

57. Oh, we are supposed to believe Beyawncy's dad? yea right! She sounds exactly like that before the studio wizards clean her screech up.

Posted at 2:42AM on Apr 23rd 2009 by Willx

58. Anyone with an ear for music can hear the change in pitch due to post production manipulation.

Posted at 7:36PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by in tune1

59. I call shenanigans...

If TMZ "found the person behind the prank", who is it? How did he do it? And why?

Or did someone just pay off the right people to say it was a hoax? I'll bet Beyonce and her label have pretty big PR budgets...

Posted at 7:41PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by Chris T

60. @"D"# 32. Y'all are so stupid. Beyonce is a vocal genius.

WOW, vocal genius???? I need to remind myself that Beyonce fans are little kids (yes 20's is considered a kid, even though I am 31) and they have NEVER heard REAL singers. Umm, does anyone remember AAliyah??? If she was still alive we NEVER WOULD HAVE HEARD of BEYONCE! She is only popular because this generation has had not talent since the late 90's. Beyonce is a FILLER for the ADD/ADHD world of singers and fans. There is NO REAL MUSIC anymore.
MARY J. BLIGE is a real ass singer, she SINGS during the filming of her videos!!! No lip syncing for a REAL SINGER!!!
Please go grab Anita Baker or Billie Holliday, listen, then come back and talk about real music.

Posted at 7:44PM on Apr 22nd 2009 by gant77