Celebrity Justice
Brooke Shields -- Shaken But Not Stirred

Brooke ShieldsSo this whole rift between Brooke Shields and Kiefer Sutherland over the headbutting incident ... here's the real story.

Brooke's reps told us that Kiefer was full of it when he said alleged victim Jack McCollough knocked Brooke over. Her reps said "nothing happened to her."

But Brooke has told friends she was indeed "jostled" by McCollough just before the headbutting, though she says it was "no big deal." Brooke says after McCollough made contact with her she fell, but not all the way to the ground. She doesn't believe it was intentional.

Brooke blames the fall on her 6" high heels and the fact that the room was dark and crowded and it was really really late.

Brooke says it all happened so fast.... but fact is, she does back up Kiefer on the issue of contact.



Tags: brooke shields, BrookeShields, head butt, HeadButt, jack mccollough, JackMccollough, kiefer sutherland, KieferSutherland

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 3) | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. TMZ GOT THE STORY WRONG YESTERDAY - CHANGING IT NOW???

Posted at 2:23AM on May 8th 2009 by colleen

2. This is very Upsetting Information.

Posted at 2:36AM on May 8th 2009 by India Vaction

3. Whatever...he won't do jail time. He will probably get sued.

Posted at 2:33AM on May 8th 2009 by astrochicks

4. Now she tells the truth! Unbelievable. Not that it excuses the headbutt, however she made Kiefer out to be a complete liar about what started it all. She also let's him be booked before she speaks up. Nice.... Kiefer needs to stop drinking and maybe this will be the beginning of the end of these situations. But she also should tell the cops the truth and not make it out that nothing happened before the argument started. And really, would it have been that difficult for the designer to apologize for 'almost' knocking her to the floor? Seriously....

Posted at 2:58AM on May 8th 2009 by A little too late BS

5. Brooke looks CRAZY lately, total nutcase. I hope that she finds some better meds and gets some skin care regimen down before she starts looking like Elizabeth Taylor -- for the love of GOD.

Posted at 3:03AM on May 8th 2009 by sumsum

6. ." Brooke says after McCollough made contact with her she fell, but not all the way to the ground. She doesn't believe it was intentional.

What does that mean, she doesn’t believe it was intentional? If she is not even sure if it was intentional how could anyone else seeing it happen know it was not intentional?
It would be interesting to see her original statement to the police.
That's all we need, men to fear being charged for a crime when they see someone getting physical with women.
When men see men pushing one another they usually tell them to relax but when a man see's a female getting pushed around it raises the tension and apparently Keifer asked the guy to apologize and perhaps he should have, even if it was unintentional which I doubt.
I can't imagine a man pushing a woman on accident and not instantly appologising, it makes no sense, sounds like the truth has still not been told.

Posted at 3:03AM on May 8th 2009 by Brooke

7. Had she told that to the police in the first place perhaps they would not be pressing charges. I also do not believe she did not know if his pushing her was a accident. Also, if it was, he should have appologised instantly before Kiefer even had a chance to ask him to.
I don't buy what she is selling, it does not add up.
Can TMZ get a copy of the police report?

Posted at 3:20AM on May 8th 2009 by So what's the truth???

8. So what I said yesterday was right.
The douchebag fop designer should have taken Kiefer up on the suggestion to apologize to the lady.
When the douchebag fop designer instrad decided to push Kiefer, the douchebag fop designer got what he deserved.
End of Story: Kiefer 1, douchebag fop designer zero.
NY and LA law enforecement, take notice.

Posted at 3:33AM on May 8th 2009 by Rick Astley

9. I don't believe a word out of her psyco babble mouth. I can't even fathom why Kiefer would be hangin around her. Somethings wrong with her. I hope she isn't off her meds. Someone should check on her children. Poor Keifer, he was just trying to defend her and this is how she repays him. Pisses me off! Brook you are a no talent has been psyco old looking hag!

Posted at 3:59AM on May 8th 2009 by liar-liar-panties on fire

10. Is that fat blubbery looking woman who is her mother still alive? Remember her when Brooke was but a child actor and the rage of Hollywood? Always butting her big and I mean very big butt into every aspect of her and our lives? She seemed to be dominating, pushy, overbearing and very very large. I am sure Brooke has struggle with her own weight at this stage of life because of her. How rude she was...if she has passed on, God Bless Her...if not, God Help Her.

the Big Tub of Lard. NO sense of personal pride in her own apperance yet pushing her childs apperance on all the world...what hypocrisy. That big fat thing, pushing her views and child on us all while she blew up like a blimp.

Please explain it to me as I have never understood those who preached and pushed one thing or image on others, yet looking at them made you want to gag.

Posted at 4:08AM on May 8th 2009 by Tears of a Clown

11. I remember when Brooke Shields dated Michael Jackson. And yes, they are my parents.

Posted at 4:50AM on May 8th 2009 by vick michaels, the aspiring veterinarian...

12. Why didn't she open her mouth before it became a big scene? She could have stopped the whole incident and arrest, if she had spoken up to the police. I have lost respect for her.

Posted at 4:46AM on May 8th 2009 by Linda Mott

13. Never liked Kiefer before this incident. Brooke the Princeton grad - what a bag. Now I know why I have not seen her lately - young girls - look at her - this is what a life of self delusion will do to you - does the bag have any kids?

Posted at 4:41AM on May 8th 2009 by john sutheerlanf

14. Brooke has not aged well she has a pained look on her face like caroline kennedy..I'm sure they are two nutty women.

Posted at 4:59AM on May 8th 2009 by beau

15. Has anyone ever seen the twot hes headbutted? Google him. I have no idea what happened there but when you see the jackhoffs picture, you just know he deserved it. Actually he didnt get beat enough.

Posted at 6:01AM on May 8th 2009 by Keifer Sutherlands hairy knees

| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments