Miss USA -- Not All Topless Photos Are Equal

There's another reigning beauty queen who took some very topless photos before she won her pageant -- but unlike Carrie Prejean, Miss Rhode Island USA's crown was never ever in jeopardy.



According to Alysha Castonguay, she dropped her top for a Maxim magazine shoot and a few swimsuit calenders way before her competition -- but there was no controversy over the pics because they were all seen and approved by the Miss USA pageant officials.

But Alysha tells TMZ she feels for Miss Cali saying, "I personally believe this situation is stemming from the controversy over her opinion and not a photo."

The final decision on dethroning Carrie Prejean is still being deliberated by the Miss USA and Miss California officials.



Tags: Alysha Castonguay, AlyshaCastonguay, carrie prejean, CarriePrejean, magazine, Maxim, miss california, miss rhode island, miss usa, MissCalifornia, MissRhodeIsland, MissUsa, pageant, topless

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 9) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

16. My Uncle used to have these kind of pictures in his 'MAN ROOM". We were not allowed to go in that room, but I went in one day and saw this type of Cheese cake type photos. You really didn't see anything that was shocking. They are art pictures. After working in a professional photo lab for 25 years, I think you have to show me something a little more shocking to call it pornography.

Posted at 8:35AM on May 9th 2009 by Linda Mott

17. I am gay and I am not comfortable with the idea that a contestant's opinion should be cause for elimination. There are a LOT of people out there who oppose gay marriage, believe me. Even some gay people are opposed to it. It's a fairly new concept that is gaining acceptance around the country, but acceptance will not be fostered by this kind of backlash.

Posted at 8:40AM on May 9th 2009 by mary apples

18. Well, well, well, it's okay for one to bare her shirt but not another?????? Give me a break!!!! Remember boys and girls it's only okay to have an opinion if it is the opinion of the popular party!!!!!
God bless America!

Posted at 8:55AM on May 9th 2009 by springs

19. I agree. Perez Hilton is out of control and has been extremely nasty and out of line. How did he ever get on the panel in the first place? Why aren't gays calling him on this. He portrays the very worst stereotype, and negatively impacts all gay people. Maybe, it is because he is only important in his own mind.
I don't have to agree with her opinion about gay marriage, but it is one held by many, including president Obama who said before being elected he did not believe in gay marraiage. Everyone is entitled to their opinion without being viciously attacked. You have to respect everyone's opinion, whether you agree or not. That is what is so great about this country. The hate brigade is what is so terrible.

Posted at 9:20AM on May 9th 2009 by Gina

20. Hey wow - If Carrie is biggoted then so is your President and MOST of the state of CA. They voted gay marriage down. I believe 70% of America is AGAINST gay marriage. Go Carrie. Keep your beliefs. Don't drink the kool-aid.

Posted at 9:21AM on May 9th 2009 by reallyirked

21. This girl is being harrassed only becasue she was asked HER opinion & gave an honest answer. I applaud her for doing that. So what if she loses her crown, she will be remembered for sticking to her guns! Lets see how many Americans do that as we move forward. She's entited to her opinion just like every one of us, for now, until this adminsitration completes its move to remove our thoughts. Not all of us are going to turn into ROBOTS. If i was asked that question & my job depended on it, I'd be unemployed today. I am sure she fears God more then the liberals or gay community. Good job Carrie. We all have to stand up for what we believe in, whatever it is.

Posted at 9:21AM on May 9th 2009 by Cindy

22. of COURSE this is about her honestly held, requested, and given opinion. everyone in the whole wide world knows it.

shame on anyone who supports LavenderMan with his ugly, nasty, self. if, for no other reason, people should shun him for his vulgarity and poisonous ways.

anyone who wants people persecuted for their opinions should be careful what they wish for. it's not often the 'crocodile will eat you last'.

Posted at 9:51AM on May 9th 2009 by Sheesh

23. #14 Get your head out of your ASS.What she said was her opinion and had nothing to do with her being a bigot.Alysha looks hot. Would like to see a photo of her with her hands down.

Posted at 10:11AM on May 9th 2009 by barney16

24. This is SO disappointing. Where are all the regular, wholesome, beautiful girls who don't think posing for salacious pictures is necessary.

Doesn't anyone have ANY standards anymore??????

Posted at 9:49AM on May 9th 2009 by Traditional girl

25. The gay community, tmz and the dirty.com are all hypocrites. So it's ok for this women to be topless but not Prejean? Then she should lose her crown as well. So much for freedom of speech. Don't you idiots have something better to report the news on than this? Leave the poor girl alove already. It shouldn't really matter. This is nothing more than a modern day witch hunt. Furthermore, those pics won't hurt her. I'd call you heterophobes.

Posted at 9:56AM on May 9th 2009 by Jeff

26. If she had said that a Black man couldn't marry a white woman I wonder if you all would be so "tolerant of her opinion?"

Posted at 10:03AM on May 9th 2009 by krb

27. The difference with this woman is she seems to not have lied about it and put it out there beforehand. Carried lied. Also, the pagent is having a problem with Carrie not getting permission to do events as Miss CA to push her bigoted agenda. Something else Carrie signed and is not following the rules on.

This lady can have her opinion all she wants. I am sure 50 years ago, a beauty queen may have offered her opinion that those with a different skin color would have to use a different bathroom in her country, or 100 years ago say women should not vote. Hopefully those who feel all people are equal would have fought her and asked for her not to represent an entire state on those beliefs, even if it was majority opinion.

She is entitiled to her bigoted beliefs, she is not entitled to a crown if she is breaking rules.

Posted at 10:12AM on May 9th 2009 by Lissa

28. Miss RH was able to clear those photos with the pageant because they were published. Carrie Prejean's panty photo was sitting in a crappy photog's drawer somewhere- that was until they were used to smear her because she spoke out against an agenda she didn't believe in. Shocking that a person would do that, isn't it? What I want to know is how come the people that call them "naked" pics or tit shots are always gay? I'm not sure what you are trying to convince the rest of us- that you see sex sex sex everywhere you look or are just fully stupid? Good luck fighting your cause with misrepresentation and lies- as far degraded the mainstream has become, it still does notice these things.

Posted at 10:16AM on May 9th 2009 by Nexilus

29. She is hot hot hot

Posted at 10:24AM on May 9th 2009 by Jordan

30. I’m glad that things turn out so quickly that we all can see some negative qualities that Miss Carrie Prejean has. She definitely does not have the qualities that a Miss California is expected to have. So, she should resign and let someone else who is more suitable to carry the duties of Miss California at this point. No need to defense her anymore!!!

Posted at 10:24AM on May 9th 2009 by Miwa

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments