Celebrity Justice
Top Cop in SJP Case: I Was Just Messin' Around

Sarah Jessica ParkerSo how's this for an explanation as to how a police chief allegedly got caught in bed with a tabloid reporter trying to sell out Sarah Jessica Parker?

Martins Ferry Police Chief Barry Carpenter -- the Ohio cop now under investigation for allegedly hatching a plot to burglarize the home of the woman who is carrying SJP's babies -- now says there's a perfectly innocent explanation to all of this. He says he was driving past the home of the surrogate mother one day when he noticed that her front door was open.

According to David Blomquist, a morning radio talk show host at WWVA in West Virginia, the ever-helpful Chief Carpenter told him he went inside to make sure things were ok, and noticed what looked like a plaster of paris cast of the surrogate's stomach. Carpenter says he looked around and left.

For some unexplained reason, Carpenter says he knew a reporter from the National Enquirer was snooping around town so he met up with him, allegedly just to "mess with him and jerk him around."

Apparently, law enforcement didn't see it that way. Investigators tell us there's some hard evidence of a conspiracy to burglarize.

Carpenter told Blomquist his home was searched and nothing was found. He says he's willing to take a polygraph.




Tags: martins ferry, MartinsFerry, matthew broderick, MatthewBroderick, police chief barry carpenter, PoliceChiefBarryCarpenter, sarah jessica parker, SarahJessicaParker, surrogate

Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 2) Previous 15 Comments

16. Dang, you'd think a cop could come up with something better than that!

Posted at 11:25AM on Jun 18th 2009 by texasangie1

17. As far as the comment about hiring a surrogate. Gee. A lot of women cannot carry a child due to complications. I am happy they can expand their family. As far as the allegations we should all wait until the investigation is over.

Posted at 11:49AM on Jun 18th 2009 by dober

18. Wow, my husbands family lives about 15 min. north of Martin's Ferry, and the small town does still live. But in an area where open front doors are common, why would he pick just that house to "check on" is not a coincidence. This woman is being stalked and now we know how, the "press" keep getting her information. As for the person who is questioning SJP's choice to use a surrogate, you do not know what her medical issues are if there are any and she owe's noone an explaination. She has had a natural child that she carried herself, so your idea that she doesn't want to ruin her body is absurd.

Posted at 11:53AM on Jun 18th 2009 by akbxray

19. If this didnt happen to SJP would anyone have heard about this? This has nothing to do with SJP and EVERYTHING to do with the corruption in enforcement ...an attitude that THEY themselves are above the law that they swear to uphold!

Posted at 12:10PM on Jun 18th 2009 by CinCal

20. Geez, her door was open so this led the guy to believe something was amiss? I live in a small town and had my door open last night I must have been in trouble - no wait it was a nice night and A/C wasn't running THAT's why. So now probable cause includes an open door. Fire his a$$ if nothing else for trying to laugh it off with the stupidest reasoning ever. The door was open.

Posted at 1:24PM on Jun 18th 2009 by SmallTown Living

21. I live in this small community and know exactly where this surrogate lived. As to the police chiefs comment he was passing by and saw the door open, it is impossible to see from the street. This house is on a hill and out of the visibility of someone just passing by. This is nothing more than his opportunity to get more of the "almighty dollar" off someone else's life.

Sorry Chief Barry, you aren't any more ethical now than you were 10 years ago.

Posted at 2:09PM on Jun 18th 2009 by small town girl

22. Wonderful story. Totally believable. Put him in jail.

Posted at 2:31PM on Jun 18th 2009 by Jay

23. Surprise, surprise...another crooked cop...

Posted at 2:40PM on Jun 18th 2009 by PIGS

24. Got Drew Peterson disease!!!!!!!!!! THE I'M A COP AND CAN GET AWAY WITH ANYTHING DISEASE
FIRE HIS ASS

Posted at 2:50PM on Jun 18th 2009 by cautious

25. This is pretty creepy. Take away his "I was just messing around" and you get, Police Chief enters the home of celebrity surrogate to get personal information for monetary gain, then proactively contacts a tabloid. Attorneys should be lining up to represent the surrogate. She has every right to go after this guy. Does he enter the homes of every single open door as he drives? How did he know this was the address of the surrogate in order to know to contact the tabloid? This is complete betrayal of the public trust as well as a personal violation. If the tabloid had printed her personal information, she could have added damages to the mix.

Posted at 3:05PM on Jun 18th 2009 by Anon

26. WHO CARES???????????????????????????

Posted at 4:23PM on Jun 18th 2009 by lynnee

27. The cops in that area are ridiculous. These are the same 2 police departments that sat back and watched my 24 year old brother get the crap beat out of him by 5 guys. They literally watched it all go down from across the street. And when all was said and done, they arrested my brother and not the guys that jumped him. Small town cops are corrupt!

Posted at 6:49PM on Jun 18th 2009 by mmg2004

28. IDIOT SARAH AND HER FREAKY WORM OF A BUTT-UGLY HUSBAND DECIDED THE PLANET HAD TO HAVE MORE SPAWN FROM HIS LIMP LITTLE PENIS. THEY ARE SICKENING. THEY ARE TOO OLD, TOO. IT'S NOT A HOBBY. IT'S A LONG PROCESS CALLED PARENTHOOD. THEY ARE FREAKS.

THIS CRAP WITH "SURROGATES" IS PATHETIC. I'M SICK OF IT. INSTEAD OF ADOPTING ONE OF A MILLION ORPHANS IN THE WORLD, THEY JUST HAVE TO PAY A POOR WOMAN A VERY MEASLY,UNGENEROUS SUM SO THEY CAN IMPLANT THEIR CRAP IN HER. IMAGINE THAT YOU GET TOLD YOUR REAL MOTHER WAS PAID TO HAVE YOU. THAT IS JUST TOO MUCH. THESE PEOPLE ARE OUT OF TOUCH AND THINK THE WORLD REVOLVES AROUND THEM. THEY ARE JUST GAS-BAGS. AND THIS WORLD IS GETTING MORE IDIOTIC BY THE SECOND.

Posted at 1:00AM on Jun 19th 2009 by Ann

Previous 15 Comments