Celebrity Justice
Top Cops in SJP Case - Did Haggling Do them In?

UPDATE: 2:56 ET: Chief Carpenter now says he jumped to conclusions -- when he was told he was dealing with a tabloid, he assumed it was the National Enquirer. Carpenter now says, "I'm not exactly sure. If the National Enquirer didn't have anything to do with this, then I publicly apologize."

Law enforcement sources tell us the two Ohio police chiefs under investigation in the Sarah Jessica Parker caper became targets after they allegedly demanded too much money for stolen pictures.

Here's what we're being told. Martins Ferry Police Chief Barry Carpenter allegedly went to the home of the surrogate who is carrying SJP's baby. We're told cops believe the chief knocked at her door and when no one answered he allegedly broke in. Our sources say once inside the chief took 15 pictures and may have tried retrieving voice mail messages left by Parker.

That's when the alleged plot really got dirty. Our sources say Carpenter and neighboring police chief Chad Dojack had concocted a plan to sell the stuff to a tabloid for $15,000. Law enforcement tells us the deal went south when the chiefs allegedly had a change of heart and doubled the demand to $30,000. The tabloid balked and the plan fell apart -- allegedly.

Now get this. The sources say the tabloid blew the whistle on the police chiefs. We're told Ohio investigators seized Carpenter's cell phone and captured the 15 pictures taken inside the surrogate's house.

Carpenter initially said the tabloid he dealt with was the National Enquirer and that he was just messing with them. The Enquirer tells us they were not involved in the caper in any way, shape or form.

Both Carpenter and Dojak are under investigation. Carpenter has denied any wrongdoing. We haven't heard anything from Dojak.



Tags: babies, burglary, ohio, police chiefs, PoliceChiefs, sarah jessica parker, SarahJessicaParker, surrogate

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 3) Previous 15 Comments

31. Police = Pigs

Posted at 1:27AM on Jun 21st 2009 by Truth Detective

32. A couple months ago I was sleeping on my couch and my door blew open from the wind and when I woke up I heard my dog barking and saw a flash light shining in my house and I thought someone was breaking into my house then when I had realized that my door was open I went outside and here stood the MFPD and instead of asking me if I was ok and if my children were ok the first thing they asked me was "ARE YOU STONED?" and if they were here to serve and protect why was there first words are you stoned? they dont give 2 hoots around here. i think most people have always thought around here that he was corrupt from the word go. I think he should be fired and so should the other because we all know that they have already worked together before and now there in on this together too.

Posted at 8:59AM on Jun 22nd 2009 by notastoner

33. First of all, it doesn't matter how much the officers earn, they swore to uphold the law. Cops like this make a bad name for good cops out there, which are the majority. Barry has hurt other innocent employees in the department for the past five years. He is corrupt and is now getting what he deserves.

Posted at 2:02PM on Jun 23rd 2009 by jeannine

34. Well, well looks like Mr. Carpenter got his hand caught in the cookie jar, again Guess what goes around comes around to bite one in the a$$. If you are a local in the town of Martins Ferry, all have to do is go to the Dutch Henry, where many of the Police officers hang out, and you wouldn't believe what you see, or hear. They also let the drunks, get behind the wheel of a car and drive away. They abuse their rights as police officers protecting the rights of citizens. Why else would an 80 year old man with demetia, be tasered. The Martins Ferry Police Department in part of certain officers, abuse their right to wear the "badge." This came from the mouth of a current Police officer. This man stated, that he had abused his rights, by being overly aggressive with a person, just because he was having a bad day. Many times.....if your a pretty or drunk girl that has just got into trouble, all you have to do i go to the back with them, you have "O" consequences. They also have issues not returning items taken from people apprehended, or just cited for a "simple" ticket. This includes everything from: jewelry, alcohol, money, you name it. They keep what they take, and share it among themselves. It would probably amaze one to have the knowledge of what the former background of a Martins Ferry Police Officer is. There isn't anything that is going to make you say "WOW." So.... if doesn't not suprise me to hear of this indiscretion. Maybe Mr. Carpenter is trying to pay for his child support, because of his other indiscretions. Those others who lost their jobs, because of him, for which I have empathy for. These people were faithful, truthful, and law abiding citizens, and employees. People who dedicated their lives to the department. Oh................I see lets weed out the truthful ones. Shame, Shame..... Being a small town, they'll get a slap on the wrist, laugh about it, and continue on in their deceitful ways. I'm sad for Martins Ferry, and Bridgeport to have such representatives. Let not the actions of two citizens reflect the pride of Martins Ferry or Bridgeport. There is always good to be found. God Bless the surrogate Mom, and the proud new parents of beautiful girl twins. I hope they do not back down, and take this unconceivable act to the highest court, if need be. If they don't, it will only continue to harm more innocent people. There may be a silver lining to this event. Possibly, a person/s who are unbiased will not be intimidated by the small town antics of bullies. These are the worst type of bullies, they wear a uniform, and are suppose to uphold society, and protect.

Posted at 9:50PM on Jun 23rd 2009 by cop mistress

35. Guilty, guilty guilty........ Just ask the community, and the drunks/employees of the Dutch Henry. But they won't talk.......it's a small town, and they have to live here.

Posted at 6:45PM on Jun 23rd 2009 by Winter

36. This totally.........cool, not. I used to think those guys were rad. Who can you really trust. I feel afraid for my friends and family who live there. Who can they call if they need help?

Posted at 8:46PM on Jun 23rd 2009 by Winter

37. I just hope this is investigated properly. The Harrison Co. prosecuter lives in Belmont county. Which happens to be the county that Martins Ferry is located in. The citizens of Martins Ferry are almost being held hostage by the police force. Unless of course, you hang out with the cops at a local bar. Carpenter has always been dirty and bragged about it. My fear is that the next chief will even be worse. I really believe that these accusations of the Bridgeport and Martins Ferry police chiefs are true. God help us if they get away with these crimes.

Posted at 9:10PM on Jun 23rd 2009 by small town victim

38. Well Well Genius, You have struck again...Only this time you got caught! Some of you folks are probably sitting there wondering how something like this could happen in a small quaint town that's nestled in the foot hills of the Ohio Valley. This mess started a long time ago ! It began with the Shrodes administration!Carpenter and his side kick became the "yes" men for the service director , who by the way was a highly intelligent man............NOT! That man could not even spell the word Bellaire without assistance! Evidently a deal was struck at one time with the service directer-------result being Carpenter appointed to the Chiefs position (when chief Canter retired) WITHOUT a chiefs test given...that was a first in the history of the Martins Ferry Police Dept. I am not surprised at the allegations brought against Carpenter as he was always taking advantage of those he believed to be weaker or below him. One example is the hell he put a homeless woman through that lived on the streets of Martins Ferry not long ago. He taunted the elderly poor homeless woman without mercy! Nobody whether homeless or not should be subject to that kind of abuse. Especially from someone who calls himself a man let alone a man who swore he would uphold the law! Carpenter proudly laughs and brags about the hurt he has caused others, and has continued to get away with it! And hes getting paid for it, I might add!!! Your tax dollars hard at work Martins Ferry Citizens!!! But maybe...,.just maybe NOT this time! Carpenter only allows the public to see him the way he wants to be seen, not the real monster he is that gets joy from destroying others, from his family to his co-workers, and yes even the public he arrests! Is there anyone out there who is wondering what the motive would be for a man in his position to take that kind of chance??? Well here's a few you can ponder over...........A divorce, child support, a 20 something girlfriend who he wines and dines and takes on expensive vacations, Ohhh and a man who is about to turn 40 soon, and still lives with Mommy!!! Hmmmmm could MONEY be the motive??? I don't know, I'm just saying.....think about it. There are some very good and dedicated men in that dept. and its a shame they are being lead and bullied by such a corrupt and deceitful leader! Speaking of leaders...What the hell is wrong with the mayor and city officials of this town, allowing Carpenter to go on working while possible felony charges are pending. Hey mayor, ever heard of administrative leave???? As for you Mr. Dojack, you have my sympathy for being soooooo STUPID and allowing your self to get tangled in Carpenters deadly web!! Thought you were smarter than that! The Chief Carpenter empire is falling and I couldn't be happier!!! If your not guilty Carpenter, whats all the chest pain and anxiety about?? How does it feel to be on the other side??? Martins Ferry....City of Dreams....one nightmare after another!

Posted at 11:45PM on Jun 24th 2009 by Who's laughing now Barry??

39. There are over 5,000 men in this city, who know that being a policeman is an endless, glamourless, thankless job that's gotta be done.

Posted at 10:15AM on Jul 26th 2009 by Joe Friday

Previous 15 Comments