Who'd you rather?
Patti vs. Marc: Who'd You Rather?

Female singer Patti Smith, 62, and fashion designer Marc Jacobs, 46, crossed paths at the same event in NYC last night.

Patti Smith and Marc Jacobs

Question is ...



Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 4) | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. Oh come on that can't be a girl!

Posted at 5:24PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Joy

2. holy heck, that is one fuggley women. no way this has to be a ugly dude.

Posted at 5:24PM on Oct 30th 2009 by donna

3. WOW, WTF happened to her. Just say no to drugs kids.

Posted at 5:27PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Judge

4. That can't be Patti Smith.... that has got to be a man. Oh Jeez, I thought you were trying to say it was Patty Smyth from Scandal. I had to check the internet...

Posted at 5:27PM on Oct 30th 2009 by No Way

5. Where's Patti? All I see are 2 guys. ??

Posted at 5:29PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Kim

6. The "Chick" on the left looks like a kiss member without makeup. And she has a nice little mustache going on.

Posted at 5:32PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Balloon Boy

7. You guys need to put things in perspective -- Patti Smith is a great ARTIST. I know this is a shock, but she's the rare female artist who didn't put their whole persona on their sexuality. This is just a cheap shot -- she doesn't ask for this sort of attention. Not nice! And Harvey, you should know better!

Posted at 5:31PM on Oct 30th 2009 by jen

8. #3 - Neither

Posted at 5:33PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Firefly

9. WOW!!

Posted at 5:32PM on Oct 30th 2009 by froggie1069

10. *********
I agree with Jen.
Let this woman ROCK & ROLL the way she wants to.

Posted at 5:35PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Jezzy

11. Are they ever going to add NEITHER?

Posted at 5:51PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Sassy

12. Patti Smith is an icon... I feel dirty for even pondering this

Posted at 5:46PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Mui

13. She was actually kind of hot at one point. Check out the cover of Easter. But the 'stache has to go at this point.

Posted at 5:47PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Chuckio

14. I agree for those who know nothing about punk rock or music altogether. Patti Smith is the oringinal Punk Poet and revolutionized Punk Rock. Sorry she doesn't resemble Avril Lavigne, but Patti is a true artist. Believe it or not she had her share of fine men, yes she is a woman and is straight. She was also married at one time and has children.

Posted at 5:48PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Polanski's Lovechild

15. Ok, well at least after I googled her she does look better in other pics so it seems this was just a bad hair day. But I did have to do a double take because it does look like two guys. And you don't have to put all your persona in your sexuality to look like a female.

Posted at 5:49PM on Oct 30th 2009 by Kira

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments