Crosby vs. Garfunkel: Who'd You Rather?

1. first! And I pick neither, they are both gross.

Posted at 12:06AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by I am...?

2. BOTH AT THE SAME TIME! LMAO!

Posted at 12:09AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by stephen

3. nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn mommy likey ROTFLMAO

Posted at 12:12AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by anna

4. WTH? I thought David Crosby passed away. I thought he was Melissa Etheridge's kids father.

HUH?

Posted at 12:14AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by who's on first?

5. hey you tmz douchebag mother effers!! how about an option C. NOBODY GIVES A SHIZZITT!! And keep that talentless 'tard miley cyrus of my computer screen.

Posted at 12:25AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by sweetest thing

6. neither why r trying 2 scare everyone,smart women have batteries or a finger if these r the last men on earth period.

Posted at 12:29AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by mickeyroxx

7. ^5'ss!! ^6!!

Posted at 12:38AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by anna

8. I'd rather cut my penis off and seal my butt up with super glue than suffer through a night of sex with either of them. Thanks for the vile thoughts, TMZ.

Posted at 1:22AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by CriticAl

9. Aw. I adore both of them as musicians, but...ahhh. God.

Posted at 3:20AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by Sarah

10. Their from a time when people listened to music with their ears insteads of their eyes.

Posted at 4:49AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by Rob

11. Next up - Who would you rather? Stalin vs. Hitler

That's how stupid this poll is!!!

Posted at 5:20AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by kdmhome

12. EWWWWWWWWWWWW and when you're gonna put the NEITHER option? GOD!

Posted at 5:50AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by Marce

13. Ew, gross choice. I'd pick DubLi way over both!

Posted at 6:06AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by newbrum

14. At least the comments are entertaining.

Posted at 6:43AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by Smiles

15. as long as either one provided the exstasy and ambien then i could probably withstand a little slap and tickle from santa and the crazy singed haired elf

Posted at 7:34AM on Nov 2nd 2009 by mzfrigginz