TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Dan vs. Rufus Humphrey

Who'd You Rather?

5/13/2010 4:35 PM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

"Gossip Girl" stars Penn Badgley, 23, and his TV dad Matthew Settle, 40, showed up to the same event in NYC on Wednesday.


Question is ...

14 COMMENTS

No Avatar

1.

KittyKittyKitty    

Yikes!



1571 days ago
2.

Julianne    

what??? no one likes Penn??
Who did Shevonne vote for?
I voted Penn. Can't resist a boy with dark hair and big brown eyes :)

1571 days ago
3.

James R. - Los Angeles    

Who the f*ck are these ***s?



1571 days ago
4.

Laylah    

Penn has a huge head...i'll go with the sexy 40 yr old

1571 days ago
5.

Pam    

I voted Cpt. Spiers.



(Band of Brothers)

1571 days ago
6.

Hula    

Spiers. So sexy.

1571 days ago
7.

Silly Rabbit    

Where the "neither" option? The first one's forehead is half his face. The other one's face is scrunched up.

1570 days ago
8.

Elmer Flobbergob    

Sorry, but I don't fool around with gays.

1570 days ago
9.

Alan     

MATTHEW CAN PARK HIS SHOES UNDER MY BED ANYTIME

1570 days ago
10.

SantaFeJack    

If you don't vote, maybe Harvey will stop these stupid "competitions".

1570 days ago
11.

DANA    

I guess Harvey would do both

1570 days ago
12.

Miss Marie    

Rufus Humphrey All The Way.

1570 days ago
13.

R    

Matthew Settle is so hot. I want him to scrub me with his scruffy.

1570 days ago
14.

Justine07    

Matthew! But poor Penn...if 73% would "rather" my mom than me, I'd be bummed.

1570 days ago

Around The Web