TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Spider-Man vs. Spider-Man

Who'd You Rather?

7/2/2010 3:04 PM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

Andrew Garfield, 26, (left) is replacing Tobey Maguire, 35, (right) as Peter Parker in the new unnecessary reboot of "Spider-Man."

0702_SPIDERMAN
Question is ... 


33 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

mel    

theyr both gross lookn

1541 days ago
2.

Carl    

This new Spider Man reboot is a stupid idea. It is obvious some studio head saw how well Twilight is doing and thought they should try to copy it. Sorry, teenage girls are never going to be Spider Man's core audience and teenage boys, like everyone else, would prefer an adult Spider Man, not a teeny bopper one (I know the new guy is 26, but he's supposed to be a teen).

1541 days ago
3.

Geoff    

Do they really think anyone will believe that the new actor is in his early teens?

1541 days ago
4.

Mark    

Spiderman wasn't a perpetual teenager, Geoff, get over yourself. He's been an adult for the majority of the story arc. What made Spiderman, was Peter Parker, Tobey Maguire conveys Peter Parker to me in the role. I don't want to see some Brit in the role, any more than I want to see the moronic idea DC has with the new Wonder Woman. Face it, it wasn't Britain out saving the world, nor has it been Europe, Russia, Latin America or China, or Japan. Those countries aren't what I think of when the term hero comes to mind.. and in all candor, it's not what comes to the minds of the foreign viewers in those countries either. I'll be passing on these new substandard rip offs.

1541 days ago
5.

Throwback kid    

Both are wimps

1541 days ago
6.

SD    

Ralph Maccio was in his 20s when he did Karate Kid. So it would be easy to make dude look like a teen!

1541 days ago
7.

Alexa    

They should have paid Tobey what he wanted. This movie's going to be such a joke!

1541 days ago
8.

Trisha    

Yuck. How about neither?

1541 days ago
9.

Tabloid Diva    

He looks a lot like Nascar driver Jeff Gordon!

1541 days ago
10.

Londoner    

i sorta agree with you #2 as iam a teenage girl and i dont fink there are many teen girls that are spidermans core audience. so they should aim it more at boys, i only like the spiderman movies coz of the story and not the spideys looks,certainly not tobeys lol he was not good looking!!. the fact is for this role they should place an adult male not some "cute" kid just to get the teens in. and if they were looking for a cute kid there were plenty of other better options!! lol. OH AND AT #4 as for him bein a brit i dont think you should be that ignorant and fink coz his british his not worthy to play a superhero coz we are u dumb yank!

1541 days ago
11.

ssdddss    

why are they replacing tobey Maguire????????
i mean seriously WHY??????????????????
i was never in to spiderman before these movies came out where Tobey Maguire had the leading role...I LOVE THOSE MOVIES!!!!!!!! I LOVE TOBEY MAGUIRE!!!!!!!! why fix something thats not broken?? ??? ?

2001: $821,708,551 worldwide
2004: $783,766,341 worldwide
2007: $890,871,626 worldwide
2012: $0 (3D really??)<<

1541 days ago
12.

ssdddss    

why are they replacing tobey Maguire????????
i mean seriously WHY??????????????????
i was never in to spiderman before these movies came out where Tobey Maguire had the leading role...I LOVE THOSE MOVIES!!!!!!!! I LOVE TOBEY MAGUIRE!!!!!!!! why fix something thats not broken?? ??? ?

2001: $821,708,551 worldwide
2004: $783,766,341 worldwide
2007: $890,871,626 worldwide
2012: $0 (3D really??) i'm not going to watch it if Tobey Maguire isn't in it SORRY!! !!! !

how bout they make the new kid a sidekick or something(???)


Oh and GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO JETS!! !!! !

1541 days ago
13.

CriticAl    

They're rebooting the series? Jeez...Hollywood has lost it.

1541 days ago
14.

chalkoutline    

Tiny little boy-men do nothing for me.

1541 days ago
15.

shelley    

Please please please please add a neither button!!!!!

((and the Spiderman movies suck anyway so it doesn't really matter who plays what)))

1541 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web