Duff vs. Duff: Who'd You Rather?

It would have to be a choice based on personality because they both look awful.

Hilary!!!!! She is too CUTE!!!! F you people who say she's not

We call that a 5 head, not forehead

If TMZ wants to make it hard for readers, try the Michalka sisters. Decisions, decisions.

Haylie looks like Vienna Girardi

Come on, guys!! Why so mean? Both of these girls are beautiful.

It's nice to see some young 'Ladies' in Hollywood these days! They are a far cry from the talentless, skanky girls who have their boobs hanging out 24/7 (Kardasians, Jersey Shore girls, etc. for example although not exactly 'celebrities') and their make-up spray painted on.

Good for these lovely girls!!!

Oh, BTW, I'm sure that all of the posters on here who are making fun of their looks, are so stunningly beautiful themselves, that they can judge these two!!!

it is YOU who says they are sisters or there is some blood sample that says so...? haven't heard from the brunette million-of-fronts in life (sorry, i'm not from USA but read you everyday!)

too easy of course hilary she should pose in playboy because she's got a smokin bod

Poor Hilary. Only 22 and already her career is washed up. Get ready Miley! Your next!

Add an "0ver my dead body" button please.

Because between horse face and rabbit face, l mean, come on!

@Alexis What the hell are you talking about? She has 2 movies in the works. Just because we don't see her around all the time doesn't mean shes "Washed up". She just knows how to keep her private life private. Miley will learn how to also.