TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Rose vs. Amy

Who'd You Rather?

12/6/2010 8:00 AM PST BY Johnny Lopez

Former "Charmed" lovely Rose McGowan, 37, and "Road Trip" babe Amy Smart, 34, held their posture at the same event in Hollywood this week.

1203-rather-rose-credit
Question is ...

17 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

JLS    

Who'd I rather? Neither. Unless you mean wash my car.

1426 days ago
2.

andy    

Rose looks okay, in general, but she doesn't even look like Rose McGowan anymore. Here's some advice, ladies, . . . be conservative with those check implants (always go smaller than the "doctor" recommends!!!). Also, not everyone looks improved with a tiny, whittled down nose . . .

Amy, on the other hand, looks much more natural and sweet like we usually remember her. Amy was absolutely hilarious in the "helicopter" scene of the movie "Rat Race".

Between these two, . . . AMY, ALWAYS!!!!!!

1426 days ago
3.

Just Sayin    

What did Rose do to her face!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1426 days ago
4.

MIDNIGHT TOKER    

I did them both last weekend

1426 days ago
5.

tig    

Unless you want you personal life torn to shambles (see R. Rodriquez), then steer as far away from McGowen as humanly possible. Besides, I think it'd be quite a shock to be with at dinner and watch her face slide off into the consume'.

I guess that leaves Amy.

1426 days ago
6.

Criss    

I wouldn't mind going where Marilyn's been.

1426 days ago
7.

MikeP    

TMZ needs to have a mod, work these comments and ban jerks like

"Posted at 5:11 AM on Dec 6, 2010 by X"

Get real, and the linked site is utter trash, so all should avoid it as well.

And Rose is mega hot.

1426 days ago
8.

JimBeam    

So is Amy at the wax museum or something???

1426 days ago
9.

TrueDat    

What the eff happened to her Rose's face! It used to be unique in a sea of same ole same ole Hollywood....now it's just wonky.

1426 days ago
10.

WaxOnWaxOff    

I would like to do the Rose from Planet Terror.. Forget the "Charmed" Rose.. Give me that stripper, "Cherry".. Great backside.. As for Amy, I loved her in Rat Race, but when she was making out with Carmen Electra in "Starsky & Hutch", she was smoking hot.. Of course her nakedness in the tub scene from "Mirrors", was nice too. Still, my preference is Rose. Amy is sweet, but I love Rose as a slutty type... Time to "WaxOnWhacksOff"... LOL

1425 days ago
11.

jen    

ATTM TMZ....for the 90th time, please put a neither as a choice....

1425 days ago
12.

andy    

Oh, come on, Jen. You know you really want to!!!!!!

1425 days ago
13.

Bob    

Rose would destroy (in a good way) most men.

1425 days ago
14.

Rick Taylor    

RATS!
I thought you were asking if we liked the Doctor Who Companions Rose Tyler or Amy Ponds.
Millions of Doctor Who Fans would give you different answers.
I say Amy Ponds

1425 days ago
15.

jonEchingas    

id rather the old Rose. She was hotter few years back.Damn you Marlyn Manson!!!!

1425 days ago
| 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web