TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Pia vs. Pia:

Who'd You Rather?

4/8/2011 9:15 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Here's shockingly booted off "American Idol" babe Pia Toscano (left) -- and the OG Pia, '80s starlet Pia Zadora back in her heyday (right).

0408_pia_rather
Question is ... 

32 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

THIN LIZZY    

Pia Zadora man.

1230 days ago
17.

jim peters    

Climbed a coconut tree for pia z. back in 1971. She's my girl.

1230 days ago
18.

AyeJay    

Pia Toscano is the perfect example of what an Italian primarily Sicilian (Southern Italian) should look like. Her tan actually looks natural, not that fake and bake sh-t the Jersey Shore cast try to pass off as a tan.

1230 days ago
19.

lesterp    

Pia Tuscano, WOW, anyone who says she doesn't have it all is an idiot. People, you used to say Celine Dion wouldn't make it. Now look, Pia has Celine quality talents. Beautiful and talented, and her voice WOW. We need to start a petition for america to NOT watch AI until they put Pia back on the show.
the voting is flawed and they know it, or something went wrong with the computerized voting system. If we don't watch they will have to listen to us and put her back on the show. She is clearly the best, AND up with the best of the best of the 10 years.
Seriously, Idol, you need some credibility back

1230 days ago
20.

lesterp    

Pia Tuscano, extremely talented, beautiful, what a voice.
Lets start a petition for America to NOT watch the show until they put Pia back on the show. If viewers are down to almost nothing they will have to listen. They got it wrong - had a computer problem --something, and they don't want to talk about it. If Americans didn't vote for her, then we should not be allowed to vote at all. Pia, she's at the top with the best of the best, of all 10 years.

1230 days ago
21.

Jennifer    

Sorry but Pia looks like a drag queen who just crossed the border into Texas. All that makeup and that huge forehead is disgusting.

1230 days ago
22.

GlobalDia    

the toscano chick is hot and all, but id take pia zadora hands down cause when i was a teenager i used to umm...think of...her all the time. :)

1230 days ago
23.

jane jackson    

I felt so bad for Stefano. A time for him to celebrate going through was deminished by the judges making such a big deal about Pia getting voted off. Pia's a lounge singer not a star, that is why she was voted off. No worry's Pia I'm sure you will get an offer from the Love Boat cruise. Stefano will be the next one to go because of the judges comments.

1229 days ago
24.

chris    

Definitely the other Pia. Toscano doesn't cut it for me. She is pretty but seems like a cold byatch

1228 days ago
25.

Bob    

Hey No. 14 David. Your comment demonstrates your I.Q. hasn't gone matured past 3. Either that or you're just a functioning illiterate. Oh wait a minute! I'm told you never found your way out of the trailer park.

1228 days ago
26.

CHARLENE    

I dont think she can sing.Its if it were a beauty contest of all them,id say they were wrong but she sounds the same no diffrence in her voice,but people who will follow the crowd and cant hear that she sucks will buy ,her garbage and will be edited as much as possible.ive heard alley cats that sound better than her if u heard her sing walkin down the street you would wont her to shut the hell up

1227 days ago
27.

Jeanette    

Well, I think she is great. And just as deserving as any of the rest of them. However, I can't quiet understand why the stage presence and entertainment is such a big deal. After all, once they make their albums and cds,they are not all videos, and most are just cds one plays in their cars, and stereo systems.

1226 days ago
28.

roger    

Yes bring Pia back and stephano go home.

1226 days ago
29.

Sure thing    

Pia Toscano has a big, big nose. She needs to get her honker fixed before she can be considered beautiful. BIG, BIG nose.

1223 days ago
30.

John 8:32    

@Sure thing : the same genetic trait that gave her the so-called larger nose that your speaking of... also gave her the wonderful skin tone and dark hair... it's called African genetics (Brunette Genes).

Believe it or not every time you l@@k in the mirror, even you will see Africa looking back at yourself.

Because in all reality the truth is there's actually only two kinds of people in this world... the first are Africans... the true people of great mother Earth. ALL the rests, people like yourself are in a category that would make you a descendant of those first people.

PIA - is a wonderful singer... and I look forward to hearing more from her very soon... actually she is a wonderful singer who got the short - end of the stick... because of jealousy.

1222 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web