Pia vs. Pia: Who'd You Rather? Pia vs. Pia: Who'd You Rather? 4/8/2011 9:15 AM PT Here's shockingly booted off "American Idol" babe Pia Toscano (left) -- and the OG Pia, '80s starlet Pia Zadora back in her heyday (right). Question is ... Share on Facebook Share on X Pia Toscano Pia Zadora Beauty American Idol Who'd You Rather? American Idol 2011