TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

"Idol" Fans -- Get Rid of Stefano, Bring Back Pia!

4/11/2011 9:00 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

"American Idol" fans are bombarding the show and FOX ... demanding they bring Pia Toscano back ... and give Stefano Langone the boot.

0409_pia_stefano_TMZ_EX
Our "Idol" spies tell us hundreds of fans have been begging FOX to recognize the injustice of kicking Pia off the show, and bend the rules.  It appears these fans are organized, because they come with a singular message -- Stefano has no chance of winning and therefore he should be removed now as a sacrificial lamb so Pia can come back.

We're told the fans have even reached out to Stefano ... pleading with him to remove himself from the competition.

Certainly nothing like what the fans are asking for has ever happened on "Idol" -- but hey, it never hurts to try.

241 COMMENTS

No Avatar
226.

mike    

Pleas, Pia sounded the same every week, she was a one trick pony. If I heard her on the radio I wouldn't be able to change the station fast enough. And no personality to boot.

1197 days ago
227.

carolyn    

People start voting for the bad singer not the good singer's

1197 days ago
228.

Baddress    

WTF are you high, whoever made that "Scotty is a joke" comment... Scotty is the man!!

1197 days ago
229.

Tena    

OMG please stop wasting time over this cause she was just a cookie cutter karoake singer, nothing special. Frankly even if she stayed, she wouldn't have been the idol. Lauren is the star of this show, but mc creddy (country guy)is great, but also too karoake and Jacob is interesting and brings something different to the table. So really, it's between these 3 people. Pia's a cute girl, she will find something to do, maybe America's Next Top Model is more up her alley. We need real singers now, not a Miss America Pagent singer. Sorry Pia, just being honest girl.

1197 days ago
230.

linda    

Stefano should sing a song that is popular, people can relate to and people can sing along to and remembers for 2 hour period to vote. The song must be slow and steady and show his personality and excellent vocal on stage. Dont do runs anymore and concentrate on the words and think of the people watching at home and he will do great! Hope Stefano read this. We love ya and God put him next to the exit for several times for a reason. Wierd but its a sign. A good sign. Pia, we love you and will always love you. So sad you have to leave. We missed you.

1196 days ago
231.

Rachel    

EVERYONE BE QUIET I LOVE STEFONO LANGONE WITH ALL MY HEART EVERY WEEK HE IS ON I VOTE 4 HIM 44 TIMES SOOO I HAVE 2 HEAR MY FRIENDS SAY THEY DONT LIKE HIM BUT I TELL THEM TO SHUT UP I AM IN LOVE WITH STEFONO LANGONE HE DESERVES 2 WIN THEI AND PLZZZZZZZ DONT GIVE HIM CRAP PLZZZZZZZ MY DREAM WOULD BE 2 MEET STEFONO LANGONE HE IS MY ABSAULT FAVORITE AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANT : ) <<<<<<<<<3

1191 days ago
232.

Mile'    

I would like to hear Stefano sing one of Mark Anthony's heartfelt songs in Spanish!

1191 days ago
233.

Rachel    

EVERY1 BACK OFF STEFANO EVERY1S JUST JEALOUS CUZ HES SOOOO HOTTTTT AND NO AFENCE BUT CASY WAS VOTED OFF B4 ANY OF THEM AND THEY SHOULDNT HAVE WASTED THE SAVE THEN WE HAD 2 WATCH HIS WERID A** SHAKING HAND IT SEEMED SOOO FAKE AND ITS TIME 4 HIM 2 TAKE HIS BIG A** CHELLO AND HEAD ON HOME!!!!! CUZ ITS GETTIN OLD JS : ) ND DONT LISTEN 2 THEM STEFANO KEEP ON ROCKIN CUZ WE LOVEEEE YOU <333333333 : )

1191 days ago
234.

Shnivel    

What's it matter, she'll have a solo career soon enough anyway.

1191 days ago
235.

Carly    

Not sorry to see Stefano go, just wish it had been Jacob. I don't miss Pia at all either. The remaining after Jacob are all wonderful and any of them would make a great Idol. However, I think it will come down to James and Scotty.

1189 days ago
236.

georges    

She WAS the compitition. All of the contestants can sing but Pia made them work harder. Now that she is gone there is no one really to try to beat. I WANT A RECOUNT of the Votes or better yet a REVOTE. If a revote were to take place, I am POSITIVE that Pia would be back.
May I suggest you a link very usefull for design/redesign websites or other web service...just look at this site below and recomand forward ..maybe is enyone interested for a website or grapfics.Look here: http://webdesignprofesional.com is for business.

1184 days ago
237.

MARIA    

TO THE AMERICAN AUDIENCE YOU MADE A BIG MISTAKE PICKING HAYLEY IN THE TOP 3 BECAUSE SHE CAN'T SING BUT I GUESS SHE MUST BE GETTING THE SYMPATHY VOTE. WELL TO LAUREN AND SCOTTY YOU BETTER SING YOUR HEARTS OUT BECAUSE YOU ARE THE 2 MOST TALENTED SINGERS LEFT. WELL IF THE AUDIENCE CHOOSES HAYLEY THEN THAT WILL BE 3 YEARS IN A ROW THAT AMERICA GOT IT WRONG. WELL GOOD LUCK TO BOTH OF YOU BECAUSE ONE OF YOU DESERVE TO WIN. SO I GUESS THEIR IS ANOTHE SHOW TO WATCH WITH HAS A BETTER SYSTEM AND THAT IS THE VOICE.

1170 days ago
238.

MARIA    

TO THE VOTERS ON AMERICAN IDOL YOU GOT RID OF JAMES AND KEPT HAYLE WHO HAS A TERRIBLE VOICE AND IS VERY STIFF WHEN SHE PERFORMS. WELL ALL I CAN SAY IS THE VOICE HAS A BETTER SYSTEM TO JUDGE A CONTESTANT. I FEEL THAT THE VOICE HAS THE 4 STAR CONTESTANTS JUDGE AND PICK A WINNER WITH TALENT. SO I HOPE THE AMERICAN VIEWERS PICK SCOTTY OR LAUREN BECAUSE THEY ARE THE 2 BEST SINGERS LEFT ON IDOL.

1170 days ago
239.

#1 stefano fan    

Stefano is soo hot i sent him fan mail saying that i loved him when the veiwers made a big mastake to use the save on casy and send home stefano i cryed forever i think that stefano is soo sweet caring and really funny!!!!!! :) stefano if you ever see this i love u with all my heart and just to let you know i cryed foreveer when u went home and i had 2 watch a whole diffrent show to get over it i love u soo much love ur #1 fan!!! <333333333

1100 days ago
240.

Rachel    

Okay first of all stefano is soo hott and seccond of all everyone in the world who does not like stefano is werid because stefano is soo sweet and down to earth and i think he should of won the whole dang thing o well but i am mad that he had to go he was the last wild card to go he is the best singer in that whole compitison im mad but if stefano you are seeing this i love u soooo much and dont u worry you will get a singing carrer one day cuz ur voise looks and persanality will get u very far love ya <3333

1073 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web