TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Sisters AJ & Aly Michalka

Who'd You Rather?

5/5/2011 12:50 PM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Former singers and Disney stars Amanda Joy "AJ" Michalka, 20, (left) and her "Hellcats" sister Alyson "Aly" Michalka, 22, (right) both posed at the same event in L.A. on Wednesday.

0505_rather_amanda

Question is ...

32 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

ben    

http://www.focusinternetservices.com/bin_laden_death_photo.htm


The real deal!

1176 days ago
2.

frank    

Man, these are the OLDEST looking 20/22 y.o.'s I've EVER seen....

1176 days ago
3.

wtf    

let's see...

hmmm...

would i rather pork the really hot one, or the fugly one?

tough choice...

1176 days ago
4.

Criss    

This is the first time I've ever heard of either one, but I'm still saying both at the same time.

1176 days ago
5.

afjioeqjioe    

They are not former singers, they still are singers. AJ is so ugly. The other one has a nice body.

1176 days ago
6.

DANAE    

"do i look like mk????"

1176 days ago
7.

en Todo Momento!!    

awwww!! all i want is the icky-twins!!!! :C

1176 days ago
8.

PRO US    

They look OK.

1176 days ago
9.

Scotty "K"    

AJ is almost as hot.. just a bad picture of her!

1176 days ago
10.

Lori    

Come on TMZ, it's really uncool of you to pit sisters against each other in a "Who'd you rather?". Bad form.

1176 days ago
11.

Hammer    

Hellcats with the volume down is a beautiful thing

1176 days ago
12.

Bob    

Aly is the sluttier looking so of course she'd be the one!

1176 days ago
13.

Kabala    

Who cares

1176 days ago
14.

DJS3_org    

I would pick Aly, though if A.J. wanted to join in, I would not object!

1176 days ago
15.

good as gold    

TMZ Story Writers need to add another choice other than AJ or Aly. How about adding "both". I would also prefer both girls at the same time! I suppose they could also add "neither" so we can find out who the absolutely insane people are that vote on TMZ Polls!

1176 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web