TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Charlie vs. Ashton

Who'd You Rather?

5/13/2011 6:15 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Here's fired "Two and a Half Men" star Charlie Sheen and newly hired "Two and a Half Men" star Ashton Kutcher.

0513_sheen_ashton_rather

Question is ...




89 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

kp    

gee I wonder who is going to win this pole
lets see no job no kids winning charlie/ with or without hookers
ashton keeps his nose clean, out of the head lines

1226 days ago
2.

sick of it    

are you serious???

1226 days ago
3.

w    

I liked Ashton until he and Demi said we need to be a servant to our president, my ass, the president serves us, now I hate that liberal douche Ashton and won't watch that show with him in it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTQawLBC59g

1226 days ago
4.

Mark Proctor    

Congratulations!

1226 days ago
5.

Jodi    

Like you even have to ask!

1226 days ago
6.

Ozzie X    

TMZ is comparing apples and month old moldy oranges.

1226 days ago
7.

TheBrain    

Haha! I like the picture of Charlie you put up. He looks tired and haggard compared to Ashton. I think Ashton is an ass but I'd take him over Charlie Sheen any day.

1226 days ago
8.

Trisha    

I keep laughing every time I look at that comparison. Come on! lol Landslide!

1226 days ago
9.

Ms Kris    

EASY ANSWER

NONE OF THE ABOVE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1226 days ago
10.

jaime    

Ashton for not the only the obvious reasons but for this: It is really easy to please a bunch of porn star tramps (charlie sheen)but it takes a man to please an older woman!

1226 days ago
11.

stacey    

As of now, I would vote Charlie, but we can't really vote until we see Ashton play the part. He may be too goofy, though. With the way Charlie has been acting, though, I really don't believe he deserves to have the part anymore.

1226 days ago
12.

Pam    

Love me some Ashton Kutcher!!!! I was an occasional viewer before, now I will never miss the show!!!! Good move by producers.

1226 days ago
13.

Elle0375    

jaime 4 minutes ago
Ashton for not the only the obvious reasons but for this: It is really easy to please a bunch of porn star tramps (charlie sheen)but it takes a man to please an older woman!


Amen to that!

1226 days ago
14.

yessir    

Is that even a question? Charlie's old Ashton is young and hot. Charlie's a drug addict psychotic pig that abuses women. Ashton is a sweet guy and family man. The only people who will vote for Charlie in this poll are men b/c they want to be like him.

1226 days ago
15.

Tall Blonde    

HELLO---- Winning! I don't "DO" druggies

1226 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web