Rachel vs. Sarah: Who'd You Rather?

Give me Buffy!

Where's the meat?

How could anyone not vote for SMG, she is Buffy the freakin vampire slayer and one of the most beautiful women ever.

they both look like ****

Ha ha....ugly is what i can say. I will pass on...aww!

I viewed a Magnum Ice Cream bar ad today with Rachel Bilson and remarked to myself, "Wow.. her teeth look yellow. Wth?" After seeing this recent picture of her, I am amazed that her teeth are indeed yellow.

Its pretty close but I seen Rachel in a red bikini and man did she look ravishing! So she got my vote!

Funny...people salivate over a pretty blond but the poll(s) usually favor wanting to 'do' a brunette.

Sarah Michelle Gellar, by far! That lady is basically a veteran, how can we forget Buffy The Vampire Slayer? When Rachel has a tv show that does that well and is STILL the talk of the down nearly 10 years after it finish, THEN she can be better. For now, Sarah wins!

Rachel looks great.Sarah looks good but she had her day.

Bison

Two very pretty Jewish girls.

Damn, now thats an impossible choice. Only went with SMG b/c I figured she was losing.......both are FTMFW. Classic beautiful and classy Hollywood babies.

That is a really unflattering picture of both of them, but especially Sarah. So much of this "who'd you rather" is based on one photo, so it isn't a shock that the results are skewed Rachel's way. I think a good picture of both would give us results closer to 50-50

BUFFY FOR THE WIN!