TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Rachel vs. Sarah

Who'd You Rather?

5/22/2011 4:30 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Television actresses Rachel Bilson and Sarah Michelle Gellar were all smiles at the same event in NYC on Thursday.

0520_Rachel_Sarah_114430886_WYR
Question is ...

40 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

CoolKid    

Can't you just make the poll show 'both' and nothing else..

Gah I would pound either with the intensity of 1000 charging buffalo.

1164 days ago
17.

Jay    

His is the hardest one of these polls ever!

1164 days ago
18.

DERMESTHETIX BLOGSPOT    

PRETTY LADIES

1164 days ago
19.

Joe Boo    

I would do Rachel while Sarah dildoed herself watching us bang.

1164 days ago
20.

tlcmk    

I still cannot believe the CW is trading in the hot young babes of Hellcats for these two tired hags.

1164 days ago
21.

princess ali baba    

rachel eat a fry PLEASE!!!

1164 days ago
22.

Back2TheFutureFan    

Absolutely love them both. Sarah will always hold a special place in my heart from Buffy the Vampire Slayer (can never forget that amazing show). Also love Rachel, but she hasn't been given a very solid role since the OC. They are actually both in NYC to promote their new shows on the CW, Ringer and Hart of Dixie. Hope both shows do fantastic, as the same can be said for Sarah and Rachel! :)

1164 days ago
23.

ChrisB    

Question is ...

what is more stupid than 'who'd you rather?'

Answer ...

Not much.

On TMZ, does the 'buck stop' with Harvey, as far as content? This almost seems like something he'd say privately - he needs an editor or someone to tell him that this is juvenile and seems more like a game that 7th grade boys might play during in school suspension or something. Although it would be ridiculously superficial, I could imagine asking, 'Who do you think is prettier?' instead. I mean, unless you're just asking men and lesbians the question. C'mon!

I'm growing more and more tired of the same ol' same ol' here and visiting less and less.

1164 days ago
24.

Jahkev    

Both lady look great;Sarah is a liitle bit oldschool, Rachel on the other hand young and fresh.

1164 days ago
25.

Curious    

Rachel is a beautiful name to go with a "gorgeous" woman!

I bet she is just as beautiful inside as she is on the outside.

1164 days ago
26.

Bri    

Rachel Bilson looks like a bobble head. Emaciated is not sexy.

1164 days ago
27.

jpm4444    

both have bodies of 8 year old boys. How about eating a meal sometime;

1164 days ago
28.

W    

Criss,

go and get your Buffy

pffffffffff..........

1164 days ago
29.

Leader of the ignorant masses    

I guess i would pick SMG because i have no idea who the other one is. I think i saw her in a commercial though. But since i am not familiar with the other girl i would pick SMG because she looked pretty good as Daphne and Buffy. And i like all of the butt kicking she did on that show.

1164 days ago
30.

JLo on Steroids    

The lesser of two ugly skeletons is Rachel. Sarah has the ugliest drip nose ive ever seen, they should be doing commercials for chili's baby back ribs with all those exposed bones. YUCK@

1164 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web