TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Nicole vs. Cheryl

Who'd You Rather?

5/26/2011 4:30 AM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

Former Pussycat Dolls lead singer Nicole Scherzinger, 32, just replaced former Girls Aloud member Cheryl Cole, 27, on the U.S. version of "The X Factor."

0526_nicole_cheryl

Question is ...

132 COMMENTS

No Avatar
76.

Mandy    

Cheryl is an absolute sweetheart from what I've seen on YouTube (I am aware of her conviction, however that was a very long time ago, a lot of our own celebrities have made plenty of mistakes and we always forgive them - this was just one mistake) and this decision to get rid of her without even giving her a chance, and without even seeing how the TV audience would have reacted is bizzare and I can't get my head around it. Nicole has the personality, as Simon would say, of a "wet fish".

1246 days ago
77.

susie    

Nicole any day. Cheryl has no talent to be judging anyone. She cant even sing live on the UK X-Factor

1246 days ago
78.

Stacey    

CHERYL! Its disgusting how us xf has treated her, and we would gladly have her back in the uk, She doesnt need xf to be a success almost the whole of the uk love her, She is the nations sweet heart. and for all the people saying that cheryl is a racist, GET OVER IT! it was like 9 years ago, the uk has moved on, its never even spoke about it, she clearly isnt a racist as she was found not guilty and she married ashley cole!! WE LOVE YOU CHERYL!!

1246 days ago
79.

right straight    

There is a reason Nicole never really took off after multiple attempts...

1246 days ago
80.

susie    

Cheryl is no longer the nations sweetheart.....she's been replaced by pippa middleton!

1246 days ago
81.

Heidi    

C'mon' guys..... You all know there's more to this & not b/cause of her thick accent..... They're whitewashing/covering up the 'real' reason......... Never believe everything you read........

1246 days ago
82.

asu    

It pisses me off that people think that because Nicole is a better singer she's more fit to be a judge. What does one's own vocal capability have to do with judging another. These are two very successful singers. They're not some average joes who know nothing about music. Cheryl has more experience judging. Doesn't that prove, if anything, she will be the better judge.

1246 days ago
83.

Ben    

When you do these Who would you rather?

You need to start adding a 3rd choice.

Neither.

1246 days ago
84.

Kelly    

What a disgrace getting rid of Britain's sweetheart. I will not watch the show anymore. You didn't even give the girl a chance. massive massive Cheryl fan.

1246 days ago
85.

Ed Hurley    

Fox screwed up on this. The only reason I would watch this show is to see Cheryl Cole. As for her accent, I love it!!

1246 days ago
86.

kloeee    

To all the Cheryl bashers, yes she was once convitted of an assault, but she's changed and grown up since then, but you idiots let it go,. Cheryl might be a bad singer, but so is Nicole, she only got famous from the ***** cat girls group, and has since had a solo career flop ever since, and has yet to make it big. Cheryl unlike Nicole does have a heart, she comes off as being approchable, while Nicole has being reportedly being a big bitch while she was in the band, and was the real reason why the band spilt, beacause she always greedy, because she always wanted to be the leader of the group. She only remained relevant in the UK papers, beacuse of her now fiancee Lewis. She is by far the worst choice for a replacement.

1246 days ago
87.

Bill    

harvey u dumb ass. u assume that everybody knows who these women are.
u do this all the time. u need to say so and so on left so and so on the right .
u dummmmmmmmy. please indentify whos who in future polls tks

1246 days ago
88.

douglas    

cherly cole has cankles

1246 days ago
89.

DCHELLE    

@yordi. Cheryl was married to a black man (Ashley Cole - famous soccer player), who cheated on her several times. A lot of self righteous people kind of fell out with her because she initaly tried to save her marriage, by taking him back. People accused her of being a doormat!

1246 days ago
90.

anonymous    

Nicole looks OLD.

1246 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web