TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Amanda Knox vs. Casey Anthony

Who'd You Rather?

10/3/2011 1:00 PM PDT BY Johnny Lopez

1003_whodrather
Amanda Knox was just found not guilty of the murder of her college roommate, while Casey Anthony was acquitted for the murder of her daughter earlier this year.

Question is ...


More Who'd You Rather?

223 COMMENTS

No Avatar
31.

JT    

This is an all time low for TMZ...Really in poor taste as are some of the comments.

As far as Amanda Knox....if you know anything about the case you know she shouldn't have ever been in jail. So putting her even in the same category as Casey Anthony is wrong on every level

If you know anything about the Casey Anthony case you have to wonder why her father wasn't on trail too.

1026 days ago
32.

B.P. Owen    

Sorry but TMZ that is just a disgusting thing to make a poll about! One who is a childkiller? I know you are a gossipsite but this is just way over the line of "normal" conduct - I have seen sleazier and even more vommit inducing tabloids be more respectful towards the victims family than you have now! SHAME ON YOU!

1026 days ago
33.

Michelle C    

This is disgusting what kind of a question is this? TMZ this should be taken off your page.... seriously?

1026 days ago
34.

whocares    

YES.YES! FINALLY THE "AMANDA" show is over for the pointed nose's ******* italian's!! to see this american paraded before the corrupt italian court like a fu..king jester was a joke !!.
HEY ITALIAN'S PLEASE TAKE "JeRSEY SHORE" AND HOUSEWIVE'S FROM NJ AWAy! MAGGOT'S !!BACK TO SICLY.1 ALL OF USE111

1026 days ago
35.

HATES SO CALLED CELEBS    

White people ALWAYS seem to walk scott free, even when MURDERING a helpless baby!!!

LATINOS WILL SOON RULE AMERICA!!!!!!!

1026 days ago
36.

HumanNature    

THESE PEOPLE THAT WORK FOR TMZ IS "DUMB AS A ROCK"!!!!

1026 days ago
37.

tucker    

The one that's not a cold blooded killer - Amanda.

1026 days ago
38.

Oh well    

I'd do Casey first, Amanda second, Casey third, and on and on.......YUMMY

1026 days ago
39.

haskel420    

i voted for casey,, i dont like a woman with kids

1026 days ago
40.

TheTruthAsISeeIt    

Hmm. I think I'd rather do the one who didn't kill her baby. Duh.. what a dumbass question.

1026 days ago
41.

HARDY-HAR-HAR    

OMG, TMZ ... WTF??! Why would you group these two together?? These two are NOTHING ALIKE ...

1026 days ago
42.

john johnson    

troy davis didn't do it either!

1026 days ago
43.

Mary    

TMZ, sometimes you guys are the most disgusting gossip website out there. How dare you glorify these two pigs??? One is a freaking heartless child murderer (please don't say SHE WAS FOUND NOT GUILTY BY 12 VILLAGERS SO SHES NOT GUILTY) and one is a lying 2 faced sociopath "goody goody" who tried to blame the murder on an innocent man and here you are asking people who would have sex with them? You guys are PIGS just like them!

1026 days ago
44.

SoThere    

This is just plain ridiculous TMZ.

1026 days ago
45.

ObamaIsAlQaeda    

The correct answer is Amanda's smoking hot sister Deanna. I'm good with a 4 way though. However, strap Casey's D's on Foxy Knoxy and I'm all in. All of it.

1026 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web