Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Justin Bieber's Baby Accuser

First Accused Her Boyfriend

Of Being Baby Daddy

11/4/2011 1:00 PM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

Mariah Yeater
The woman who claims Justin Bieber fathered her child -- originally accused her ex-boyfriend of being the daddy to the very same baby last year ... this according to her ex-BF's grandmother.

TMZ spoke with Frances Lippe ... who tells us Mariah Yeater had been dating her grandson John Terranova in Las Vegas toward the end of high school.

Lippe says Yeater came to their home in December 2010 and told Terranova she was pregnant with his child. He insisted he did not get her pregnant.

The two got into an argument and police were called ... because Yeater allegedly broke a car window out of rage.

Later that day, according to the police report, Yeater returned to the home to work out a payment plan for the window ... and got into another altercation with Terranova ... and allegedly slapped John 3 separate times in the face with her open right hand.

Yeater was arrested and charged for battery.  A court date has been set in Vegas.

Lippe tells us they never heard from Yeater again after the December altercation. 10 months later, Mariah surfaced ... now claiming Bieber is the father. JB says it just ain't true.

Mariah gave birth to a baby boy in San Diego on July 6 -- she did not list a father on the birth certificate.

We've made multiple calls to Yeater's attorneys -- so far, no response.

Terranova reiterated our story to the NY Post, saying Yeater originally tried to pin fatherhood on him. He added, "I know it's not Justin Bieber ... She just wants money. It's a scam."



No Avatar

John Graves    

She ain't that bad lookin, I'm tellin you. All you freaks have pictures like that on your dumb fakebook accounts, don't act like you only have modest portraits. I guarantee you have stupid pics on your fakebook. Probably flashing a gang sign or drinking a panty peeler while flashing a gang sign above your cleavage. You think you look awesome, but actually you look just like this chick.

There, someone had to tell you.

1047 days ago


She likes high school boys (like her ex) and doesn't seem to know who fathered her child. Just how many high school age fathers could there be? I hope she has help b/c children raised by crazy mothers don't tend to end up mentally stable.

1047 days ago


She looks like something out of a tackle box. She looks gross and low class.

1047 days ago


Ok, here we go again. One thing that these mysterious "he's my baby daddy" stories have in common is usually the girl is ultra-delusional, and typically has accused someone else of being the father BEFORE she accuses a celebrity. Which is the case here.

I particularly love how she accused her ex-boyfriend, who denied it. She goes postal & leaves. She then returns TO WORK OUT THE TERMS OF A PAYMENT PLAN, despite the fact that he denies being the father. To these ultra-delusional women, it's all about getting paid. Sorry, chicky; rejected! Just like you're going to be rejected when the paternity test is done...

1047 days ago


Oops; misread that. She returned to work out a payment plan for the window...

1047 days ago


This does not surprise me about her. She probably accused a few other fellows during that time.

1047 days ago


I don't think that Bieber is an angel by any means. But lets examine some things. He currently has a beautiful girlfriend. Even if he didn't have her he probably has access to some very beautiful and wealthy women. Why, why, why would he touch this ignorant looking, broke-assed, nobody psycho. Who in the hell is this nut anyway? This fool has been watching waaaaayyyyy too much reality t.v. She is making a fool of herself and will come to deeply regret her actions concerning Bieber.

1047 days ago


Her mother also filed a paternity suit according to a San Diego blog. On the job training.

1047 days ago

Different Rules Apply    

Tackle box! Now that made me laugh for the first time all day.... She is just gross.

1047 days ago



1047 days ago

the artist formerly known as hand turkey    

The sooner you take the test, the sooner it will be over. Don't wait until the court orders you to.

If it's negative, move along.

They keep talking about suing her, she's on public assistance though, probably can't get anything besides a gag on her.

1047 days ago

John Graves    

It doesn't matter how "hot" some chick looks, or how "beautiful" and "famous" she is, guys are gonna always cheat with trashy women that put out on the spot. Trashy strange chicks give up the trashy strange sex, AND WE LOVE IT.

Arm candy is nice, but outer beauty fades quick. Trashy strange is what guys want. Put that on the cover of cosmo.

1047 days ago


Someone please take this woman's child away from her - I smell a child-abuse case in the offing. She sounds emotionally unstable and maybe delusional.

1047 days ago


Of course she's not going to list a father. She needs to find a sucker first. Judging by her piercings, she's such a whore, even Maury couldn't find the real father of this one. I feel sorry for the baby boy.

1047 days ago

Cravin Morehead    

This chick looks and acts like a psycho nut case. She has no business having a child. Just what the world needs---another unemployed loser in the world!

1047 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web