TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Xtina vs. Kelly

The Bandage Dress Battle

Who'd You Rather?

11/28/2011 12:00 PM PST BY Johnny Lopez

1128_xtina_kelly_ratherWearing a form fitting white bandage dress, Christina Aguilera showed off her stunning talents at the AMAs last week, while Kelly Clarkson belted out her hits in a copper colored version on "The X-Factor."

Question is ...


See also

More Who'd you rather?

111 COMMENTS

No Avatar
31.

Mary    

There are so many times I want to vote on this, but you don't ever have a box to check for NEITHER!!!!

871 days ago
32.

June    

I don`t understand why people are criticizing
Xtina and Kelly,
mostly Xtina, it`s not like every person that commented negatively has a perfect body. Stop being judgement and judge yourselves for being ignorant/rude and contributing to a very big problem in today's world!, BULLYING!!

871 days ago
33.

afjioeqjioe    

They both look like fat pigs. Neither of them should be wearing that.

871 days ago
34.

nephilim3    

What A Whore !!

871 days ago
35.

KATHERINE    

THEIR STYLISTS SHOULD GET FIRED FOR THIS... COME ON NOW.. REALLY?

871 days ago
36.

E    

Christina looks like Aretha Franklin omg I cant imagine that's "what a boy wants"! Lol

871 days ago
37.

DENA    

kelly clarkson look good on that dress and look like diva too kelly. from your fan Dena.

871 days ago
38.

Anthony03    

Hands down. Kelly. She seems to be naturally pretty inside and out. None of us know them personally, but based on interviews and what not, I bet Kelly would be unbelievably fun to hang with.

871 days ago
39.

Spider    

Both have fantastically curvy bodies and probably look unbelievably sexy in person. But the dress style isn't one that is suited to curves, it's more suited to the frail, straight body type. Since clearly neither woman is overweight, it's ashame that both picked dresses that would give that appearance. I do love that you cannot count the ribs ABOVE their b.oo.bs for a change, which seems to be all the rage in Hollywood anymore.

871 days ago
40.

sky    

Looks like the car seats on my dad's 1959 Buick.

871 days ago
41.

StevenB    

Kelly doesn't really have the body to carry that dress off - it makes her breasts completely disappear - but at least she doesn't look like she is on her way to the corner to start her 'shift'.

Kelly, get a grown up haircut, 'kay?

871 days ago
42.

thejadedentrepreneur    

Xtina has weird looking implants. At least Kelly's flapjacks aren't smooshed and falling out of the top. Neither one of them is in the shape to wear one of these dresses though.

871 days ago
43.

Savage    

Wow, they both need to start off with black material, once they do that I'll come back and give a 'nice' opinion...

871 days ago
44.

hollywoodlander    

wow when did christina get so freaking fat! A couple of lardazzzzes. Might do em at closing time if I had the beer goggles on. Sober? No thanks

871 days ago
45.

karlew    

Ha. I wore a dress very similar to Kelly's to my daughter's wedding this summer. Of course I lost 46 lbs before I'd even attempt it.

871 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web