TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Xtina vs. Kelly

The Bandage Dress Battle

Who'd You Rather?

11/28/2011 12:00 PM PST BY Johnny Lopez

1128_xtina_kelly_ratherWearing a form fitting white bandage dress, Christina Aguilera showed off her stunning talents at the AMAs last week, while Kelly Clarkson belted out her hits in a copper colored version on "The X-Factor."

Question is ...


See also

More Who'd you rather?

111 COMMENTS

No Avatar
46.

Nancy    

Harvey would look better in this dress than either of these two women. Honestly, I have to wonder whether there are ANY mirrors in Hollywood!

975 days ago
47.

Bird    

Neither one of those women have any business wearing that dress.

975 days ago
48.

barney    

Not even a contest Christina wins.She has nice full curves,Kelly has no boobs.

975 days ago
49.

2drk2fck    

NOTHING IS WRONG WITH THEM! ITS YOU AND YOUR ANOREXIC NOTIONS which looks disgusting BTW and sickly and druggie gross. They are singers not under fed models you could only dream of having a voice like theirs. God this world is so effed up...

975 days ago
50.

jujubee    

I don't get it, TMZ puts up a post about people like lindsay lohan and miley cyrus and everybody talks about how talentless and worthless they are BUT then tmz puts up pictures of two talented women- kelly clarkson and christina aguilera- and people want to complain that they're fat and ugly?? They're not fat nor ugly and even though they're in the public eye, lets not forget why they're famous..BECAUSE THEY CAN ACTUALLY SING

975 days ago
51.

Arog    

I wouldn't turn either away. Both look healthy, unlike the skin and bones that most woman in entertainment are today.

975 days ago
52.

Feel Sorry For Her    

Girls, Please look in the mirror before you perform in front of millions of people. Your stylists should be fired. Also the people around you that said you looked "thin, great, Dress really flatters your shape" What ever your yes people are telling you. LOOK IN THE MIRROR. FIRE YOUR STYLIST. Start hanging around people that will actually tell you how you really look and not tell you what you want to hear.

975 days ago
53.

James    

Kelly...HANDS DOWN. Kelly has an ass like no other. Keep in mind she's only like 5'2", put that in perspective....she's MUCH smaller in person than you think she'd be. Besides, it really looks like Christina has a huge bowl under her shirt, or is pregnant or something....Kelly's stomach appearing is just part of her curve.

975 days ago
54.

Leader of the ignorant masses    

There is nothing wrong with a woman who has some meat on her bones. Better this than the bony trend in Hollywood like that Lohan sister. I'll never understand the Hollywood and modeling obsession with bony women. Why anyone would find a woman who does not look like she hit puberty yet attractive is beyond me.

975 days ago
55.

Yolie    

Neither! Let's dress appropriately for our current shapes everyone.

975 days ago
56.

Yolie    

Neither! Let's dress appropriately for our current shapes everyone.

975 days ago
57.

Rita    

No offense but that dress would not look good on you if you were 98 pounds. Oh thats right Kim K can pull it off if all you want to see is her ass stretched to the max..LOL

975 days ago
58.

cokeandpilates    

Think this is a case of just because you can fit into it doesn't mean it looks good. Christina looks like 10lbs of sugar in a 5lb sack and Kelly Clarkson just needs to go change. The hideous hiny fabric is not helping the situation at all.

975 days ago
59.

john johnson    

ok..there're both so dam fat! what the hell do they eat these days?!?!

975 days ago
60.

Kabala    

Neither - they're both pigs

975 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web