TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Madonna vs. Kelly Clarkson

Who'd You Rather?

2/5/2012 12:30 PM PST BY Johnny Lopez

0203_madonna_clarkson_rather
Queen of Pop Madonna is performing during the halftime show at the Super Bowl, while original "American Idol" Kelly Clarkson is singing the national anthem.

Question is ...

More Who'd you rather?

169 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

Poncho Llama    

Lmao..you guys are awful. I would lez out with Kelly over Madonna any day of the week. Kelly might be soft but Madonna's gini probably looks like something from Tales from the Crypt.

804 days ago
17.

Chris    

Kelly Clarkson all the way. Love her. She is amazing and sweet as hell. Her voice gives me chills, and she is adorable!!! I am a fan of Madonna too, but Kelly is my Diva!!!!

804 days ago
18.

SYLVI212    

Is that just a terrible picture of Kelly, or has she really packed on the pounds? I knew she had put some weight on but she looks downright FAT in that picture. I never would have known it was her if I weren't told. As for Madonna, the majority of you who claim you don't like her because she is "old", her age matters not. She is an egotistical, no talent, selfish POS that thinks the entire world cares about everything she does, thinks and feels. If only she were as talented as SHE thought she was.....

804 days ago
19.

Slomoshun    

You guys really need a neither button.

But..I would pick Kelly, pre weight gain.

804 days ago
20.

JWS    

I would have voted for Madonna in the eighties but now she's way burned out...

804 days ago
21.

raven    

she is NO QUEEN OF POP. Kelly all the way.

804 days ago
22.

krisCanada    

not enough choices! I would have gone for neither...

804 days ago
23.

zenny    

TMZ, please always provide a third vote choice: "Neither" Thank you!

804 days ago
24.

Dennis    

Apples & Oranges Johnny Lopez!!! Thank GOD we don't HAVE to choose. Clearly Kelly is the better singer and Madonna is the CONSUMMATE entertainer. The End!

804 days ago
25.

AntiSocialForum.com    

Doing Madonna you'd probably catch something.
-
Doing Kelly, you couldn't catch "being fat".

804 days ago
26.

jason    

Oh why would any sane man want to boink Madonna?? Eeewww

804 days ago
27.

Omnipotent1    

F... You NEITHER!! Not with your di..!!

804 days ago
28.

Davey    

where the F**K is the neither button!!!!!?????@%@^@#^@^^@%^*%()$^%&*$^@@@@!!!!!!!!!!!

804 days ago
29.

Dan    

Well since I already had my turn with Madonna (Rochester Adams class of '77) I had to go with Kelly.

804 days ago
30.

Mick Kahler    

Madonna has done the 'dance with no pants' with so many hundreds of guys,.eww! Trying to 'do it' with her would be like putting a hockey stick into a garbage can.

804 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web