TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Madonna vs. Kelly Clarkson

Who'd You Rather?

2/5/2012 12:30 PM PST BY Johnny Lopez

0203_madonna_clarkson_rather
Queen of Pop Madonna is performing during the halftime show at the Super Bowl, while original "American Idol" Kelly Clarkson is singing the national anthem.

Question is ...

More Who'd you rather?

169 COMMENTS

No Avatar
31.

Jimmy jamz    

Kelly is a fattie

991 days ago
32.

DON COOPER    

If the Superbowl people were smart they'd replace Madonna with Kelly after this poll. Nobody wants to see a entertainer who's career has benefited from payola since the early 1990s.

991 days ago
33.

Hank    

Madonna blows old snaggly mess. This is the best they could do I know I won't be watchin

991 days ago
34.

Sara    

I agree, Madonna is a nobody, she had a hit once or twice in the 80s but geesh people move along. Kelly didn't do good singing the National Anthem at all, so now I vote neither.

991 days ago
35.

DON COOPER    

Most people would rather have sex with ELVIS alive or dead than they would with Madonna at any age. Madonna is not the true legend that "THE KING" is no matter what lies Billboard Magazine are telling the public now. Billboard hasn't been relevant since before they allowed payola to determine their weekly charts in the early 1990s. Your lies are catching up to you, Madge.

991 days ago
36.

Terri    

it really depends on the song...I like them both.

991 days ago
37.

Tom Papers    

madonna is damaged goods. Who would want to **** that
whore ????????

991 days ago
38.

andy    

I'm gay but if i had to pick, it would be Kelly, lol!!!! Love her to death! She will rock the National Anthem tonight!

991 days ago
39.

Ian Gillan    

Who'd you rather?

...ah, rather what?

Who'd I rather listen to?
Who'd I rather make love to?
Who'd I had rather be friends with?

KELLY CLARKSON would be my answer to ALL the above.

991 days ago
40.

Gita    

Hello Madonna is way older and looks way hotter. Kelley looks like a pig. Realty.

991 days ago
41.

frank    

Madonna is soooooooo old and gross!

991 days ago
42.

M    

I came in thinking this was an easy choice, Madonna is getting old fast, after all. My question is when did Kelly Clarkson get so fat and unattractive? Is she on an all mozzarella stick diet? I could have sworn she used to be, if not smoking hot, quite cute. Plus she wants Ron Paul to be president, did she lose some IQ points too (mainly all of them).

991 days ago
43.

AntiSocialForum.com    

Everyone knows hoes and fat chicks are only good for BJs.

991 days ago
44.

sokolniki    

Where is the "NONE OF THESE" option?

991 days ago
45.

Gita    

Madonna Baby.Kelly can't even get a man. Daaaaaaang. Not even if she bought one.

991 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web