TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Madonna vs. Kelly Clarkson

Who'd You Rather?

2/5/2012 12:30 PM PST BY Johnny Lopez

0203_madonna_clarkson_rather
Queen of Pop Madonna is performing during the halftime show at the Super Bowl, while original "American Idol" Kelly Clarkson is singing the national anthem.

Question is ...

More Who'd you rather?

169 COMMENTS

No Avatar
76.

Joshua    

nty I prefer madonna.
kelly clarkson's bangs make me want to vommit.

993 days ago
77.

kaja    

MADONNA BRILLiANCE!

993 days ago
78.

Jess    

Kelly Clarkson!! ♥

993 days ago
79.

mar    

both were great.. kelly has an awesome voice, but madonna "sang" 4 songs!!! (2lip-synck) and danced 15 minutes non stopping... so GO MADONNA

993 days ago
80.

Fred Garvin    

Hindsight is 20-20.....we now know Madonna sucked....lip synched entirely.

993 days ago
81.

TheBride    

Forget these idiots. The GIANTS WON!!! Eli and the G-men are the REAL STARS!!! We love Eli!

993 days ago
82.

Wellington     

Madonna's half time performance was pretty ho-hum. She definitely can't dance the way she use to. Trying to still be a cheerleader at age 53 is kind of pathetic and her cutting edge has become as dull as a butter knife.

993 days ago
83.

anonymous    

No guy would want to get near old hag bag Madonna.

Madonna is the sloppy seconds of Dennis Rodman.

993 days ago
84.

MR. DNA    

I've been with buff 50 year old chicks and chubby 29 year old chicks and I'll take the 29 year old every day of the week and twice on Sunday.

993 days ago
85.

DetroitRocks    

Madonna carries too many diseases and Kelly might be a virgin

993 days ago
86.

Susan    

Don;t understand what the problem is with Madonna doing the half-time show, I thought it was superb. Such a nice change compared to the last four shows. Most of the singers you cant hear over the music, typical of Janet Jackson..she is such a weak singer you can't hear her over any music. Madonna did a half-time show that you didnt have to cover your kids eyes to watch. A show even Madonna's kids would be proud to watch. As for Kelly Clarkson, you can't compare the two singers but Kelly did a great job on the national anthem, didnt even miss a note nor a word. Congratulations to both ladies...Don't be a hater...give both women their credit do.

993 days ago
87.

gj    

madonna of course!!!

993 days ago
88.

Uncle Jed    

All I can say (without being censored) is; "Whiskey-Tango-Foxtrot!" What was that? All that was missing were slaves mixing mud WITHOUT straw! Whatever the NFL paid for Mad-Madonna...They got Ripped! Fortunately, no animals were harmed (or used) during the show. For a moment I thought I was witnessing another massacre of 'Jerry's Kid's' on a Pay-for-View. But this was not the Labor Day telethon. It would have been better to have the Octagon set up in the 50 yard line and then throw Mad-Madonna in as an Under-card event. Maybe even have her fight a donkey (or jackass) and watch her get a pair of double horse-shoes tattooed on her ______! I do not understand why the NFL has to appear to stretch the limit of "Good-Taste...Gone bad! Next Year (oh yea) just get some college bands Like Jackson State, Grambling and or Bethune-Cookman University Marching Wildcats provide REAL ENTERTAINMENT! These musicians are experienced (Super Bowls), Novel, and are choreographed in good taste!

993 days ago
89.

Denver    

Another AWFUL rendition of the National Anthem. Can we just have the song without all the changes in octaves to prove your range! Don't make the song sound like a country ballad!!! Yeck. My vote is Neither btw.

993 days ago
90.

Uncle Jed    

Lets see, profane, bizarre, and memories of trailer park life: Must be Madonna!

993 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web