« BACK TO TMZ TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Colts Star Dwight Freeney

Andrew Luck vs. RG3

... Who's Better??

12/5/2012 11:51 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

120512_dwight_freeny_launch
Andrew Luck has the better record ... Robert Griffin III has the flash ... but when it comes to the NFL Rookie of the Year award, it's like "Highlander" ... there can be only one. 

So, who deserves it? We ran into Indianapolis Colts superstar Dwight Freeney on the streets of NYC yesterday ... and though you might expect him to lean a certain way, he told us, "Both of those guys ... too much talent ... those guys have too much talent."

1204_andrew_rg3

Of course, he also noted that Luck is "Amazing" ... duh.

So, we gotta ask ...

For more sports stories, check out tmzsports.com!
43 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

Franc    

Who cares? Is this a sports blog now?

687 days ago
2.

Mikey    

White men make the best quarterbacks cause they're smarter. Asian would be the best cause their brains are big but they're to small to play football. Blacks are best at the other position in football for the reasons stated by Jimmy The Greek. And Spanish are no good cause just look at Sanchez.

687 days ago
3.

DAX_SEACREST    

how many ads does tmz need to stop my computer

687 days ago
4.

kennedykh    

LUCK ALL THE WAY

687 days ago
5.

brothermouzone    

RGIII right now. RGIII has one of best passer ratings in league, while Luck is near the bottom of the league. RGIII also more of a threat in the run game. I like Luck though and think he may eventually be the better QB down the road. Rookie of the Year is close though because Luck's team does have the better record and is more likely to make playoffs.

687 days ago
6.

cass    

Luck without a doubt.



I'm 100% a Giants fan too.

687 days ago
7.

witz01    

Russell Wilson.

687 days ago
8.

Bigdogg    

Brady!

687 days ago
9.

Fuck Celebrities    

Who are these two idiots?

Are they actors?

Are they singers?

Are they comedians?

What sort of azsholes is Harvey hiring now?

687 days ago
10.

OH ESE!!    

Britney spears

687 days ago
11.

dopernose    

RG3 can RUN and THROW THE ACCURATELY the ball... that's a perfect combination!

687 days ago
12.

Ace    

Best team name in sports: REDSKINS

A racial slur now and then never hurt anyone.

We still count scalps

687 days ago
13.

USA#1    

They both are playing great for rookies. They both bring something different also. Too soon to say. Have to give them a couple of more years. They both seem like good guys though, unlike that selfish turd Cam Newton.

687 days ago
14.

Ca2Az    

Kapernik

687 days ago
15.

Shaunie    

That Robert Griffin sure is hard on the eyes! Glad I'm not a redskin fan, yuck!

687 days ago
| 1 | 2 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web