« BACK TO TMZ TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Colts Star Dwight Freeney

Andrew Luck vs. RG3

... Who's Better??

12/5/2012 11:51 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

120512_dwight_freeny_launch
Andrew Luck has the better record ... Robert Griffin III has the flash ... but when it comes to the NFL Rookie of the Year award, it's like "Highlander" ... there can be only one. 

So, who deserves it? We ran into Indianapolis Colts superstar Dwight Freeney on the streets of NYC yesterday ... and though you might expect him to lean a certain way, he told us, "Both of those guys ... too much talent ... those guys have too much talent."

1204_andrew_rg3

Of course, he also noted that Luck is "Amazing" ... duh.

So, we gotta ask ...

For more sports stories, check out tmzsports.com!
43 COMMENTS

No Avatar
16.

RobN    

Long term, it's Luck. RGIII is going to take too many hard shots with all that running and it'll take a toll on his career. He already had his first concussion this year and it doesn't take many before you can't pass the baseline test anymore to get off of IR. Luck is going to spend 15 years throwing passes and breaking records.

584 days ago
17.

$$    

Russel Wilson of the Seattle Seahawks has outdone BOTH of them...

584 days ago
18.

MTG    

Who ****ing cares?! They are both overpaid neanderthals who can't even perform basic math, I'm sure.

584 days ago
19.

RealityBites    

Wilson #Seahawks

584 days ago
20.

neglky    

Bledsoe

584 days ago
21.

cass    

No not at all...

P.S. - Look at the standings before making asinine remarks!

584 days ago
22.

malcsteez    

Andrew Luck graduated with a degree in Architecture Design... Robert Griffin masters degree in Communications. BAAZZIINNGGAA!

583 days ago
23.

NOT ELMO    

They Both Svck...

583 days ago
24.

HungWang    

both great, but the Cults won two games last year, so thats you're rookie of the year. It is very difficult to stereo type them because both they both seem to do everything well and communicate even better.

583 days ago
25.

kagiso    

TMZ..I AM DISAPPOINTED
YOUR EAST COAST BIAS IS SHOWING
RUSSELL WILSON OF THE SEATTLE SEAHAWKS IS CLEARLY THE BEST ROOKIE QB THIS YEAR!.

583 days ago
26.

kagiso    

TMZ
I AM DISAPPOINTED...YOUR EAST COAST BIAS IS SHOWING!
RUSSELL WILSON OF THE SEATTLE SEAHAWKS IS CLEARLY THE BEST ROOKIE QB THIS YEAR.

583 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2

Around The Web