TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

'Whale Wars' Star

I Didn't Sink That Boat

1/16/2013 8:40 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

0116_capt_paul_watson
Paul Watson -- the animal rights activist who stars on "Whale Wars" -- tells TMZ he's been FALSELY accused of sinking the famous Ady Gil anti-whaling ship ... and is now pointing the finger at the ship's captain.

We broke the story ... Watson is being sued by the ship's namesake Ady Gil -- who claims he owned the vessel and leased it to Watson's Sea Shepherd organization. In his suit, Gil says the ship suffered minor damage in a fender bender with a Japanese whaling ship in 2010 and could have been repaired -- but Watson secretly had the ship destroyed so he could blame the whalers and gain publicity for his animal rights group.

But, in a statement to TMZ, Watson denies ANY wrongdoing and says ... "It seems like Ady Gil is simply frustrated that he could not get justice from the Japanese whalers who did sink his boat and has decided to lash out at us [Watson and the Sea Shepherd Org.] instead."

Watson claims the person who should REALLY get the blame for the crash is the ship's captain -- Peter Bethune -- who "negligently stopped his ship in the path of the whaling vessel and it was cut in half."

Watson says there is video of the crash that backs up his story.



Watson adds, "Peter Bethune was never under my command and I did not give him any order and I certainly did not order him to destroy his own ship." Watson says he was 250 miles away from the boat at the time of the crash.

Watson says Bethune eventually made the decision to abandon the vessel in the open water because the damage was so extreme, he couldn't tow it to port for repairs.

Bottom line -- Watson says he shouldn't be held responsible for the fate of the boat because "the Ady Gil was not a Sea Shepherd ship and was not under my command."

Check out Watson's entire statement after the jump.



Response from Captain Paul Watson to the Ady Gil Lawsuit
 
This lawsuit filed by Ady Gil is somewhat mystifying. It seems like Ady Gil is simply frustrated that he could not get justice from the Japanese whalers who did sink his boat and has decided to lash out at us instead.
 
His timing is also mystifying in that he waited three years and filed this suit just as we arrived in the Sanctuary this year to protect the whales. He also waited until we were battling an injunction by the U.S. Courts filed by Japan at the same time I have been made a fugitive based on accusations by his skipper Pete Bethune.
 
I really don’t have the time to deal with Mr. Gil’s strange lawsuit until after we have chased the whalers from the Southern Ocean this year, but when we do get around to answering him, I am sure our lawyers will have little trouble dismissing this suit as petty and frivolous.
 
The Ady Gil was owned by Ady Gil and skippered by Peter Bethune. Ady Gil bought the vessel from Bethune and hired him to be the skipper of the vessel. Pete Bethune selected his own crew. They were not Sea Shepherd crew except for one Sea Shepherd member on board as a liaison. Peter Bethune was never under my command and I did not give him any order and I certainly did not order him to destroy his own ship.
 
One only needs to watch the video to see that Bethune negligently stopped his ship in the path of the whaling vessel and it was cut in half. New Zealand Maritime Safety investigated the collision and their report clearly states that the loss of the Ady Gil was caused by 50% negligence by Pete Bethune and 50% negligence by the Japanese whalers.
 
That is the result of the official investigation which contradicts these allegations by Gil.
 
I was 250 miles away at the time of the incident.
 
The Ady Gil was cut in two and unsalvageable. Despite this the crew of the Bob Barker not only saved the lives of the Ady Gil crew they thought they might be able to tow it to the French Research base in Antarctica. Towing it back 2000 miles to New Zealand was impossible. The Bob Barker towed it for 35 hours and it was like towing an open bucket through the water. They could not make any progress and with a storm on the horizon the waterlogged halfsunk Ady Gil would soon become a hazard to the Bob Barker.
 
Finally the Captain of the Bob Barker called me as asked what to do. This conversation was recorded for the program Whale Wars. I said, “It is Pete’s boat and thus Pete’s decision.”
 
Pete Bethune made the decision to abandon the vessel and Australian Maritime Safety was informed of the fact because it would be a navigational hazard. The vessel was not sunk, it was abandoned and the decision to abandon it was made by Pete Bethune.
 
Proof of this is that the Japanese crew on the Shonan Maru No. 2 came across the floating half sunk hulk of the Ady Gil the next day.
 
Pete Bethune had a phone call with the designer of the boat who gave him the opinion that the vessel could not be salvaged. And he was right. The vessel was cut clean in half and her engines flooded. I did ask Bethune if he wanted the Bob Barker crew to salvage the engines for him and he told me that they could not be salvaged.  The vessel was not repairable and considering the remote position of the vessel, it was unrealistic to expect it could be towed, especially since there was 200 miles of ice between the ships and the French Research Station.
 
We were never in a position to take care of the boat. That responsibility was in the hands of Pete Bethune who worked for Ady Gil, not Sea Shepherd.
 
Pete Bethune boarded the whaling vessel that destroyed his ship to confront the Japanese captain. He was arrested and brought back to Japan where he made a deal. By accusing me of ordering him to board the whaling ship he received a suspended sentence and the Japanese charged me instead. However as the video evidence shows clearly, I advised Bethune not to board the whaler. He answered that by saying he would take full responsibility for his actions. It appears he had a change of mind.
 
So to sum up, the Ady Gil was not a Sea Shepherd ship and not under my command. It was owned by Ady Gil and under the command of Pete Bethune. As her captain it was his responsibility to look to the safety and security of his ship. As I was not in command of the Ady Gil I had no part in any decision regarding navigation or operations of the vessel and I made no decision to abandon the vessel.
 
Ady Gil may have the money and the time to waste on this frivolous lawsuit but we really have much more important priorities, the first of which is to stop the Japanese whaling fleet from illegally killing whales in the Southern Ocean Whale Sanctuary.
 
Ady Gil paid Pete Bethune a million dollars for the vessel and now he wants us to give him five million dollars. Unfortunately for him he does not have the evidence to back up these unsubstantiated allegations. We on the other hand videotaped everything.
 
But the question must be asked: Did Ady Gil send his boat down to the Southern Ocean to support Sea Shepherd’s campaign to save the lives of the whales or was it just to have his name on a boat that would be in a TV show?  Personally I did not get the impression that Mr. Gil was that concerned about the whales. When his name was painted on the boat originally, he told Bethune’s crew to remove it and put it back on in larger letters.
138 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

Mazor    

Yeah sure, just like you didn't fake that shooting in season 1 you lying sack of ****.

616 days ago
2.

Mazor    

Paul Watson deliberately endangers his crew because the publicity he can get by martyring them is worth more to him than their lives.

616 days ago
3.

DeeMaree    

Ok then.

616 days ago
4.

rikki    

Well he's certainly not going to admit he did...the man's a fanatic and a fame whore who will do whatever he can for himself and his cause.

616 days ago
5.

david    

this dude is crazy....he acted like he got shot one time (terrible acting btw)...he rams japanese boats and he puts whale life above human life...just like an extreme peta person....i watch the show and pull for the fisherman

616 days ago
6.

Sapphiegirl    

Yeah...if he is soooo innocent then WHY did he resign from his charitable organization then? People don't resign unless they either retire (from the looks of it he ain't even old enough yet!) or due to a scandal. Misleading the public that subsidizes your organization via donations is very scandalous and would create a financial problem for the org when all the donors stop donating! I hope all your theatrics were worth damaging your organization to the point of it failing. If it fails...WHERE WOULD THE WHALES BE THEN??????

616 days ago
7.

David    

douche

616 days ago
8.

Who the Hell is Khloe    

Who?

616 days ago
9.

Mustard    

Sadly all of this gets more attention then the fact that Japan kills more then 1,000 whales for supposed research each year. You may not care about whales but I assume some like to sea food nd swim in the oceans. Without whales the very delicate Eco system is in jepordy. I appreciate what the sea shepards are trying to do but it is starting to make the Japanese look more credible in this situation. Well maybe not credible but it definitely gains them empathy in the eyes of the public. You can't always be liked to get the job done, I just wish they were actually making headway in this fight instead of it being a battle of who's boat is bigger,badder and faster. If you do like whales the is a movie called "The Whale". It's about an orca named Luna that stayed in a bayin B.C. He wanted everyone to pet him and he would even turn boats around with his nose so people couldn't leave! Amazing movie but it highlights the issues we have with blurring the lines of what's safe for the animal and what the people want

616 days ago
10.

buzz kill    

Lying POS.

616 days ago
11.

Carl    

I'm a conservationist and people like him really upset me. The extremists get all the press by doing things that piss people off. That turns people against conservationists in general, hurting the cause more than helping it.

616 days ago
12.

A Wilson    

Watson's recollections are a bit fuzzy. He says in his statement, "Peter Bethune was never under my command..."
The fact is that Bethune WAS under Watson's command as per the terms of the agreement Sea Shepherd signed.
From the Charter Agreement for the lease of the vessel to Sea Shepherd (Charterer) pg 4:
"Chaterer's Authority Over Crew
20) It is mutually agreed that full authority regarding the operation and management of the vessel is hereby transferred to the Charterer for the term thereoff."
http://www.protecttheocean.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/ADY-GIL-CHARTER-AGREEMENT-FINAL.pdf

Watson says that the Maritime NZ report on the collision assigns 50% blame to each party. This is misleading. The report found fault with both parties but does not apportion that fault as a percentage. Both at fault does not equate to equally at fault.
"... both were responsible for contributing to and failing to respond to the “close quarters” situation that led to the accident."
http://www.maritimenz.govt.nz/news/media-releases-2010/20101118a.asp

see report items 16, 17 for purpose of report
http://www.maritimenz.govt.nz/AdyGil/Investigation-report-Ady-Gil-Shonan-Maru-Hi-rez.pdf


Bethune was largely placed in this vulnerable position by the failure of Sea Shepherd to refuel the vessel Ady Gil. The first failure was Watson leaving the AG earlier in the campaign in order to shake a tail ship as he headed back to port to refuel the Steve Irwin. The second and most obvious failure was that of the Bob Barker who left the AG with very little fuel and a several day wait for the returning Steve Irwin.
This suit is hardly frivolous and if the timing of this suit seems to be a piling on of another suit on top of two Interpol red notices for arrest, a suit by Bethune, an appeal in a suit brought by a Maltese tuna company, and the suit in US District Court; then this seems to say more about how Sea Shepherd and Watson are conducting themselves rather than Mr Gil.

616 days ago
13.

SoWhat    

Anyone that knows Paul Watson will tell you that he'd absolutely order the captain of a boat to do what happened there, he's a nutjob that lost any credibility many years ago.

616 days ago
14.

DaveT    

He's upset about *allegedly* being falsely accused?
Like the way he faked being shot and falsely accused the Japanese of shooting people? Slandered them and never admitted his lie?
Left the country and world to believe they shot him?
Unless he ever admits he lied and apologizes for the slander, he deserves to be sued by various people and lose every penny he's stolen from people who donate and funding sources.

616 days ago
15.

John Doe    

Sugar Daddy ADY is a wimp and a hypocrite who only wanted to be able to say "look I'm sooooo great I have my name on a SSCS ship" and when his puppy Pete Bafoon destroyed it due to stupidity and insane whalers he made up a lot of lies to destroy the only group who defend and protect the whales!!

616 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web