TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Eddie Murphy's

Old Chick vs. New Chick

WHO'D YOU RATHER?

6/24/2013 9:30 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

0624_nicole_murphy_paige_butcher_rather_splashHere's Eddie Murphy's 45-year-old ex-wife Nicole Murphy on a beach in Miami yesterday (left) -- and 34-year-old Australian supermodel and current Eddie Murphy girlfriend Paige Butcher on a beach in Hawaii one week earlier (right).

Both are incredibly sexy... but only one is a mother of five.

The question is...

86 COMMENTS

No Avatar
31.

Dmariejrzy    

I really think Hollywood & Media forgot about a woman's curves! Nicole might be a milf, but she has feminine curves. New & younger lux almost anorexic.

453 days ago
32.

Jarvis    

Look out Eddie. White women are a black man's Kryptonite!!

453 days ago
33.

static    

Tom Petty said it best. Take back Vanessa Redgrave Take back Joe Piscopo Take back Eddie Murphy Give 'em all some place to go

453 days ago
34.

UNLEVINED HARVEY    

both are noticeably enhanced

453 days ago
35.

rikki    

Hmmm those bodies do not look in the least bit natural, but they are pretty. Eddie clearly has a type.

453 days ago
36.

Anna    

I don't understand why anyone would choose Skeletor in the red bikini.

453 days ago
37.

Marcia2942    

Nicole looks better because she's more curvy, the other one is too thin and has bones sticking out. She could eat a couple of pork chop sandwiches with extra mayo, and perhaps that would help with the sickly look.

453 days ago
38.

BECKER    

Has anybody noticed that there aren't any likes or hates? I guess TMZ is too busy helping the Kartrashian clan with the baby lawn jockey

453 days ago
39.

Lisa    

I honestly think Eddie is just with Paige for the company. I really don't see Eddie with her for the long term.

453 days ago
40.

Promise    

Nicole

453 days ago
41.

b003    

I liked Scary Spice better, super sexy and raunchy.

453 days ago
42.

angelina    

the new one is sickly looking skinny. disgusting!

453 days ago
43.

Arcadia Rink    

Nicole is one of the sweetest most down to earth women in Hollywood. She's a great mom and just a great person. Not pretentious at all.

453 days ago
44.

Sili'LilSkoolgrl    

What are we comparing, tummy tucks? Both have the telltale downward pull and lipo cavities near their hip bones. NEXT!

453 days ago
45.

Big Mark 91    

I am sure that ***** is beyond beat if she has had 5 kids

453 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web