TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Justin Bieber

Smoking Gun in Egging Case

Surveillance Video

2/10/2014 9:30 AM PST BY TMZ STAFF
EXCLUSIVE

0209-bieber-egg-getty-tmz-01The L.A. County District Attorney has surveillance video that should make it pretty easy to prosecute Justin Bieber for allegedly egging his neighbor's house ... TMZ has learned.

Law enforcement sources tell us ... The L.A. County Sheriff's Department's recommendation to file felony vandalism charges focuses on 2 pieces of critical evidence:

-- Surveillance video seized during the raid at Bieber's house.  Our sources say ... the video shows Bieber in the vicinity of the area where the egging occurred at the time of the attack.  You don't actually see him throwing eggs, but he's there.  Sources connected with Bieber told TMZ earlier the video shows nothing, but that's NOT true.  The Sheriff's Dept. has given the video to the D.A.

-- A video obtained by TMZ in which you hear what sure sounds like Justin Bieber verbally going at it with the neighbor in the middle of the egging.  At one point you ever hear Bieber scream, "F*** you!  I got another one for you actually."  The video is too dark to actually see him.

In addition there are 2 eyewitnesses ... the neighbor ... who openly has beef with Bieber -- and his 13-year-old daughter.  The girl made a 911 call which our sources say matches the time Bieber was seen on the surveillance video.

The 2 videos make it almost impossible for Bieber to deny he was throwing the eggs -- it would be shocking if the D.A. doesn't file criminal charges.

The open question -- will the D.A. file the case as a FELONY or a misdemeanor?  The neighbor has submitted repair estimates totaling around $20,000.  If a vandal destroyed an expensive car the D.A. would probably view it as a felony.  The issue is whether the D.A. will appreciate that eggs can cause that much damage on an expensive home.

The D.A's decision should come down this week.

011014_bieber_eggs_launch_v3

273 COMMENTS

No Avatar
46.

dark    

That is TOTALLY his voice, no doubt about it. Either way, if he is throwing the eggs himself or he had his friends doing it, he can be prosecuted.

As a felony, it depends on the evidence of the damage done

258 days ago
47.

Nobody Special    

Now the beaver knows to throw water-balloons at someones house. This way it will only be a misdemeanor and not a Felony.

Maybe he can fill-up some of those Condoms he carries but never uses as water-balloons.

258 days ago
48.

missdiva22    

that is bull **** lies about justin bieber people have done worse then eggs

258 days ago
49.

FLUX    

So the Sheriff's Dept. is giving the DA two video's? One
that does not show him throwing eggs and the other one that is to dark to show him throwing eggs? Some stories are hard to follow.

258 days ago
50.

Keke75p    

Crap I've egged and TP'd people I don't think I was 19 but glad they weren't rich w cameras. Jeez, we played ding dong ditch, all kids of stuff, so sorry I just can't take this serious because who would think an egg would cause so much damage they musta been hard boil.

258 days ago
51.

BB not bb    

I remember on mischief night people would expect to get toilet papered, soaped and egged on their property. Some guys would hide in the bushes and jump out with garden houses to keep the kids away. No one called the cops after or made a big deal of it. They just went out and cleaned up the mess.

Now the USA is so touchy, you can't hardly breathe without it being a felony. Someone who is out to get you has any number of means at their disposal. This nonsense about Venetian plaster is ridiculous. It isn't Venetian if some California mason put it on. It isn't like DaVinci came to plaster the house.

258 days ago
52.

Tommy    

deport the little WIGGER and his sh-t for brains black friends. All useless trash. Oh, and send his wigger daddy along with......

258 days ago
53.

david 183    

Who the fock cares. Nothing will happen to him anyway. With the money he has he will just keep on making a mockery of the system.

258 days ago
54.

Gsharon 710    

Why in the hell are they worried about one house owner's egged house, when we have a family of nuts, sure to endanger the safety of airline employees, his own staff, and people on the streets. He can easily pay for the damage to the house, but you cannot replace a love one.
There are hundreds of people in prison today who were charged falsely with crimes, because they could not afford an attorney, and the case loads were stacking up. The lawyer tells them to settle, then tack on ridiculous time as the minimum, and these would be our own. One day this will be brought to the front, when we have people with guts and voices to yell to help these people. Send this little brat home. He can still make music there, and the silly kids can still buy his music . These ass kissing lawyers, judges, DA's, and young lawyers will one day get backbones, and admit to the chit they are doing, when the person in prison has missed some of the most important happenings in their, and their families lives. Send the puke h o m e! A visual difference between the poor and rich.

258 days ago
55.

She's baaaack    

Justin Bieber is such a little tvvat. Trying to get street cred so he can hang with the other rich "ghetto" rappers and his pasty white pansy ass gets busted for throwing eggs. I wish they had him on film, not because it would have sealed the deal but because I'm sure he throws like a 7 year old girl. Send his little ass back to Canada. They saw him fcuking up at 14 and shipped him to the USA so they could blame it on us.

258 days ago
56.

Toddy Walters    

If the police decide a crime is committed it's up to the District Attorney to decide if there is enough evidence to a.) file charges and b.) take it to trial. It's no longer the choice of the victim. A crime is a crime is a crime, regardless of who committed the crime or whether or not anyone deems it serious.

This is how our criminal justice system works. Maybe it's different in Canada.

258 days ago
57.

Sophie    

Dear TMZ, get the **** out of here with your stupid news we all (beliebers and justin and TMZ

258 days ago
58.

alex    

Anything ANYTHING to make this lil boy go away

258 days ago
59.

fastdriver    

TMZ, DON'T be shocked if criminal charges are not filed! There will be another "loophole" to get him out of this too! If enough money is available, the DA will lessen the charges! HOW can you be shocked when you see EVERY DAY how the legal system in LA works! It is a JOKE to the rest of the nation!

258 days ago
60.

Fry Daddy    

Didn't we already know there was surveillance video?!?!

258 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web