Kylie Jenner vs. Sarah Hyland Who’d You Rather?

10/26/2015 12:01 AM PDT

Kylie Jenner vs. Sarah Hyland -- Who’d You Rather?

Kylie Jenner (18) donned her signature dark lips and pumpkin hue hair at a fashion show last month (left) ... and Sarah Hyland (24) with a blonde fringe bottom bob and Halloween lipstick at a West Hollywood party last week (right).

The question is ...