17 Reasons Why Pia Toscano is the Real 'American Idol' Winner

4/8/2016 12:09 AM PDT

A new American Idol may have been crowned last night ... but the real winner was season 10 contestant Pia Toscano

The sexy singer -- who was voted off the show way too early despite her amazing voice and killer good looks – showed up and showed out during last night’s performance at the series finale, reminding America the mistake they made five years ago.

Check out the gallery to see Pia’s sultry snaps and to get reacquainted with the hottest contender.