Lindsay Lohan ignited a huge debate in our newsroom -- did she really hit that NYC pedestrian? We've got the surveillance video now, and just like the Zapruder film, everyone's seeing something different. Sooo ... let's fight about it. Plus, Paris Hilton ... gay-friendly or raging homophobe? She claims her comment -- "most [gay men] probably have AIDS" -- was taken out of context. You buying that? And OJ Simpson's old cohort Kato Kaelin calls in to refute a report that he said OJ really DID commit the murders -- and he's threatening major legal action.