1. her personality seemed "thin" as well. she doesnt look healthy and she has lost too much weight! get your burger on!

Posted at 10:13AM on Mar 9th 2007 by trixy

2. She looks skeletal compared to 2005. She looks like she has taken it too far...

Posted at 10:13AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Rachel

3. Another case of normal doesn't cut it in the big lights of celebrity. She looked pretty last night, but she also looked pretty when she was "normal". Hope she's feeling okay with her new life.

Posted at 10:16AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Vicki

4. I think she is just naturally pretty. Kellie Pickler does not hold a candle to her. There is nothing at all fake about her. I hope she continues to succeed for years to come.

Best wishes Carrie!!

Posted at 10:16AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Donna

5. Of course she lost weight. Imagine the pressure that she is under. I'm just glad she didn't go the other way a la Kellie Pickler in the boobs department.

Posted at 10:16AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Christina

6. I think she looks great either way. However, it seems the norm to say that her before shot was "plump". She looked just fine before, but I am sure someone somewhere told her to loose a few... creeps.

Posted at 10:19AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Allison

7. Carrie is awesome!! I thought she looked beautiful as usual!

Posted at 10:20AM on Mar 9th 2007 by sick sick sick

8. .........................OK ,baby girl....Keep your head on straight.....You are radiant!!!!!

Posted at 10:21AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Old Dog

9. i like carrie underwood she a beauriful talented human being and she is so down to earth. if more stars would act like that they wouldnt be made out of a joke

Posted at 10:22AM on Mar 9th 2007 by KIM

10. i thought she looked great

Posted at 10:23AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Iowa Girl

11. She is a bit on the "too thin" side, but weight fluctuates...maybe she stresses out when cutting a new album or hitting the award circuit like she has been. Maybe her thinness last night isnt the norm. Having said that I think she cannot afford to lose much more. She is very very talented..but one thing I've noticed from last night and from the music awards...someone needs to teach the little miss to dance!.. yikes

Posted at 10:25AM on Mar 9th 2007 by jen

12. Your comments: She looks sick now...and was never plump. She is underweight
now, but
was normal before.

Posted at 10:26AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Dawn

13. CArrie Underwood is beautiful no matter what she weighs!!!! She is a class-act .....so gracious and beautiful all the time. What a whirlwind year she has had.......keeping that busy is enough to make anyone shed 10 pounds.....I don't think it was intentional - she has said that she just doesn't have alot of time to sit around and eat.
America got it right and she is just a STAR - I love her and can't wait for her next CD......great outfit too!

Posted at 10:28AM on Mar 9th 2007 by lynn

14. Have a couple of burgers, honey. She looked better(healthy) @ her normal weight.

Posted at 10:29AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Milkshake&Fries

15. I thought she looked beautiful and confident and I can't believe anyone in their right mind would ever consider her plump during her time on America Idol. It must be a slow news day!

Posted at 10:29AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Anonymous