McPhee Wants Her MTV

1. Katharine - will you marry me?

Posted at 3:52PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Travis

2. Get real! Kat on TRL.....don't think so.

She sucks!

Posted at 4:02PM on Aug 24th 2006 by WTF?

3. UGH! why would they put that crap ass song on MTV? you had your 15 minutes...now disappear in to obscurity please.

Posted at 4:11PM on Aug 24th 2006 by lala

4. Katharine thinks that she has done something new and innovative with "Over the Rainbow." If anyone wants to hear a really INCREDIBLE version of "Over the Rainbow," listen to the late Eva Cassidy sing it! FANTASTIC!!

Posted at 4:56PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Lizzy

5. I COMPLETLY AGREE #1 and 2. This idol wannabe needs to dissapear quick. Paris and Mandisa wer way better and one of them should have been runner-up. She can't sing and is everywhere. Go away!

Posted at 4:56PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Ykon

6. Will all the American "Idles" please just stop. Nothing's new. Nobody is innovative. Why don't you yawners wait til they have the $500 round robin at the local karoake hang out.

Posted at 5:17PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Phil

7. Kat is a very talented singer,albeit there is no comparison to the likes of Mariah Carey.However,her version of Somewhere Over The Rainbow is excellent.But one will need to watch Judy Garland perform in The Wiazard Of Oz to see the all time best classic version of the very famous and popular song.........

Posted at 5:32PM on Aug 24th 2006 by gary

8. Who the Fuck THINKS THey did a good job on that 30 second piece of shit, completely pointless!

Posted at 5:55PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Nick

9. Is this the only song this girl can sing?? She thought she was going to win American Idol with one song. Every damn talk show she was on, she sang this song. Sing something else already!!!!!!

Posted at 7:07PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Rye

10. She just wants the rest of the world to join her in throwing up. At leastshe seem to be good at that.

Posted at 7:51PM on Aug 24th 2006 by Joseph

11. no matter what you all say, Kat is great.... She is absolutely beautiful, she can sing very well and she's absolutely beautiful (did i say that already?)

Posted at 1:55PM on Aug 25th 2006 by Sergio Fibonacci

12. WHAT IS ALL THE HYPE ON MCPHEE SHE WASN;T VOTED # 1 IT WAS TAYLOR HOW COME HIS NAME ISN'T IN THE SPOTLIGHT. EVERYTHING I SEE ON AOL IS MCPHEE, MCPHEE, MCPHEE GET A LIFE AND SMELL THE ROSES

Posted at 12:12AM on Aug 26th 2006 by EDNA ALBRIGHT

13. Love, love, love her.

Her haters are so predictable. You smell the roses, and figure out that T**ty Hicks is yesterday's gimmick. Sorry. But that's what he is.

Posted at 12:51AM on Aug 26th 2006 by Loki

14. I think Paris Hilton is trashy I heard her music today for the first time & it was nasty If she was to be on a street corner & with no money & talk & sing the way she does now she would be called a slut & a whore,because the music that she has is awfullSo why is it that Paris is not being called all those names & the other girls that are doing the same thing and acting the same way Paris is ,is getting called sluts & whores Shes not no better than they are in my book

Posted at 2:08AM on Aug 26th 2006 by Beverly

15. I think Edna needs to wake up and "smell the coffee"

Posted at 8:36AM on Aug 26th 2006 by deebee