1. I say let them do a paternity test on Maury!

Posted at 2:14PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Amanda

2. For the baby's sake, I hope Eddie is not the father.

Posted at 2:15PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Dottie

3. I'm more interested in the Larry Birkhead article on the upper right corner of the cover!

Posted at 2:17PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Susanne

4. Actually, I heard tell that that might be SnappyG's baby. He likes the sistas!!!!

Posted at 2:17PM on Apr 25th 2007 by E. Alneda

5. For the child's sake, I hope Eddie is not the father.

Posted at 2:20PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Dottie

6. Eddie Murphy should be ashamed of himself! He knows they were together at the time she got pregnant which is part of the reason he left her - she wanted to keep the child and he already has 5 by his ex-wife.

Chris Rock was a man about his case - he says he welcomes a paternity test and would contribute to the care of the child if it is his (though he asked for one 10 years ago when this first surfaced and the woman backed down).

Eddie Murphy is a dog for trying to ruin Melanie's reputation by saying he "suspects" she was sleeping with someone else - only a low down dirty dog would sleep with a woman then deny a child might be his.

If he suspected she was cheating on him then he should have worn a condom! There's a lot worse he could get from unprotected sex than a baby.

Posted at 2:25PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Just my opinion

7. First of congrats to Scary. It takes lots of courage to be a single mother and have a baby on your own, especially when you have asshole men out there, we walk out on you and leave you to fend for yourself. I have No repect for Eddie Murphy, he needs to step up to the plate!!! If he doesn't scary, take him for all the child support you can, he pays for his other children, this one should be no different. Money can't buy happiness or a baby, and just thank God you have such a blessing - for free!!! Tell asshole Eddie to read Psalms 123 "Children are a gift from God." Take the cash, raise the baby with love. I wouldn't let Eddie see the baby though (even if he doesn't he's still required to pay support) she may feel abandoned by him from his current and potentially future actions. What you have done is SOOOO GREAT...YOU GO GIRL!!!

Posted at 2:31PM on Apr 25th 2007 by You go Girl!!!

8. #6, Just my opinion; Preach it to the choir baby. You're damn right.

Posted at 2:34PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Dottie

9. TMZ you are becoming sleezy...Why was this comment added to a paternity story.


If her claims are true, Eddie's behavior towards Melanie seems especially troubling, considering what a Good Samaritan the Oscar-nominated star usually is. In 1997, Murphy famously helped his fellow man by giving a ride to a transsexual prostitute.

Posted at 2:35PM on Apr 25th 2007 by MamaMe

10. He should step his Buckwheat Ass up to the plate. A Real man wouldn`t act like a mouse

Posted at 2:35PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Amy NY

11. That is seriously raw. He just dropped her like she was trash. Eddie should have been concerned about her pregnancy and the baby instead of trying to run so fast the other way. What a no-good-dog!! His new girlfriend could care less that it's his baby so why is he trying so hard to distance himself. What a disgrace to real fathers everywhere. Congrats Melanie, what an absolutely beautiful baby, just a doll!!!

Eddie, be a man and step-up instead of running like a puppy. You know you are wrong!

Posted at 2:42PM on Apr 25th 2007 by E. Alneda

12. DOES ANYONE KNOW THE CIRCUMSTANCES BEHIND HIS DIVORCE? JUST CURIOUS? HE WAS PROBABLY A DOG TO HIS WIFE!!!

Posted at 2:49PM on Apr 25th 2007 by cleveland1

13. HEY NUMBER 7 - TONTOLINO:

SHE IS NOT A GOLD DIGGER. They dated for awhile. Eddie is a scum bag who should at least be a man and take a DNA test. Dont blame her. You must be a man. A woman in her right state of mind would not defend Eddie.

Posted at 2:49PM on Apr 25th 2007 by Joanna

14. His wife filed for divorce because she got tired of him screwing Johnny Gill, Arsenio Hall, Sugar Ray Leonard and any little transvestite he could get his tool into.

Posted at 2:54PM on Apr 25th 2007 by spiceitup

15. Murphy should accept this like a man. Sure looks like it could be his. Be a man Murphy. Hopefully its not his kid. How can you watch a movie knowing the star making all this money is being such a s##thead? DNA will set you free if you are right.

Posted at 2:57PM on Apr 25th 2007 by joanne