TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Who'd You Rather?

10/6/2007 1:01 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

"American Idol" judge Simon Cowell turns 48 on Sunday, while "Idol" champ Taylor Hicks turns 31.
Simon Cowell, Taylor Hicks
The question is ...

71 COMMENTS

No Avatar
1.

Jolly    

First to say Simon is a hottie!!!

2539 days ago
2.

Lia    

Ummm....neither!

2539 days ago
3.

Sarah Silverman SUCKS!    

Simon. I love irritable hairy men.

2539 days ago
4.

BigD    

I would rather shoot off my penis with a shot gun.

2539 days ago
5.

Norte Wood    

SIMON??? Well, Iguess if he were my choice, he would have to leave my house before first morning light. I wouldn't want my neighbors talking about him OR me.

2539 days ago
6.

Shanna    

I agree with Willow and..uh..kinda with hottdawg805. You guys need to put "Neither" as an option.

2539 days ago
7.

Jamey    

Simon if he wasn't 112.
And Taylor if he didn't look like Jay Leno's and George Clooney's mutant baby.

2539 days ago
8.

Only swim in the Ocean    

I would rather they do each other with Perez in the middle.

2539 days ago
9.

Miss Carol    

How come you don't hve a button for "NEITHER" or "EWWWWWWWWWWWW YUCK - NEITHER" ?

2539 days ago
10.

Angel    

Ick...

2539 days ago
11.

Dawn Buttimer    

Double ICK.

I'd rather see Wayne Newton naked that do either of these two.

2539 days ago
12.

worm    

OK TMZ We need a niether button..... no choice there.

2539 days ago
13.

Meme    

Who would you rather what? You don't say. Who would you rather take out the trash? Who would you rather have clean your carpets? WHAT? #4 - TOO funny about using the shotgun but I bet that'd leave a mark and ruin your drawers. I remember when I said If I hear that freakin soul patrol crap ONE more time........KABOOOM!!!!! I can sing better than him and I make peoples' ears bleed. Still, given the choice.... I'd rather it be Simon who comes over to clean my house..can he wear a french maid outfit? Hey ..equal time for us women, okay?

2539 days ago
14.

LaughsLikeThunder    

31!?!?! Are you shiznitin' me? Seriously? Seriously!

2539 days ago
15.

chicodude    

hottdogg805 echoes my sentiments perfectly. Well put.

2539 days ago
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web