"Idol" Contestant a Giant Phony?

The kid sucks. He's not singing he's yelling and if he ever did have a voice, he'll wreck it completely singing that way. Trust me.

Syesha mercado or whatever her name is has been on tv before

and another one has had a record out...

this is not surprising. TMZ, how research all the contestants, not just one.

Watching David perform is like watching little childrens beauty pageants. Sure, they look good..and sound good...but its all too staged. Theres no reality in it. Wheres the reality tv?

Josiah would've been perfect for this..he was entertaining to watch! And he wasnt a stage monkey.

I wonder if that hurt him as bad as it hurt me.

Bring back Josiah....

People doubt their talent all the time. All real artists understand that.
Naturally since there are no real artists at TMZ this idea would have escaped you.

The kid looks like a gay little tranny

Bring back Josaiah? Are you kidding. THAT kid was a pretnetious little twerp. You're living in your car, kid? YOUR choice. Get a freaking job.

did it ever occur to you that maybe he doubted his talent because he's went through the traumatic experience of losing the use of a vocal cord?

This guy did sing when he was younger and was on Star Search. He hasn't broken any rules and he probably doubted it because of his vocal cord paralysis. Stop demonizing everyone!

This isn't news. It's been out for a while that most of the top 24 have had some sort of success (even if it's TEEEEEEENY) already.

Hell, Britney Spears' ex-boyfriend (who just so happened to open for her a lot of years ago), Is one of the top 24.

I think he is a cute little guy. And I hope he goes far in the competition.

Hey Evan Knudsen....you were 3rd and 6th........not first. F**K OFF!!!

doesn't bother me as much as the Irish chick who's had millions spent on her album which flopped - no mention of THAT by the judges and the fact she changed her last name to throw people off is kinda shady. (think she sucks btw).

so what hes got a great voice