Earth to Paula -- Come in, Paula!!!

16. Could it be the judges are present during dress rehearsals? That might explain why she was quick to judge his second song - maybe she already heard it prior to taping. Still, Paula is not very sharp when drug induced.

Posted at 12:56AM on Apr 30th 2008 by Allen

17. Haters !!!
Go easy on Paula. She has to work about 3 hours a week. She is suffering from exhaustion !!!!

Posted at 1:30AM on Apr 30th 2008 by SS

18. Paula looks to me like the kind of short hairy musky woman who smells reeeeeeeal bad, you know...down there.

Posted at 12:56AM on Apr 30th 2008 by Herman

19. Well Simon did say in interviews that the judges do watch the dress rehearsals and use that to judge the performances.Wow Paula looked a mess tonight her hair was a bird's nest,but in her defense MAYBE she got frazzled by not beable to fully comment.I still DON'T see where this proves AI is rigged.

Posted at 12:57AM on Apr 30th 2008 by Lollie

20. Seems like she accidentally gave away the secret that not all the performances are done live. I imagine that she did see both songs and just forgot that it was being shown out of order.

Posted at 12:58AM on Apr 30th 2008 by jstuddle

21. All jokes aside is this women for real just wondering?

Posted at 12:59AM on Apr 30th 2008 by It's 5 O'Clock Somewhere!!!

22. Who cares! That stupid show is on its last legs anyway. That's why I stop watching after the auditions. And they're not even as funny as they were in the beginning. I can't believe people are still watching. Even the American Idol people know they show is on its last legs. That's why we are getting all of this "inside information" all of a sudden.

Posted at 1:06AM on Apr 30th 2008 by blacgirl

23. hahaha..... thats it.... its funny

Posted at 1:41PM on May 3rd 2008 by Tamara

24. Yes, midgets DO have periods.

Posted at 1:06AM on Apr 30th 2008 by Herman

25. You can hear Randy say a few times just the FIRST song just the first one. He did sing twice and she wasn't suppose to let us know that. She does seem like she is on something but saying real quick I thought you sang 2 songs was her just trying to quickly cover her goof.

Posted at 1:13AM on Apr 30th 2008 by me

26. Simon noticed, and said to her "you really like Brooke, don't you?" My feeling is they saw dress rehearsals, but wasn't supposed to let on they knew what the second songs would be or sound like. Any case, the format sucked- the songs and their individual critiques should be done separately. It became rushed at the end and you had to force yourself, sometimes against your will, to remember the first songs...

Two impressions- David Cook is over-rated but the most creative. And really, truly- Brooke at her best.. IS the best.

Posted at 1:16AM on Apr 30th 2008 by auramac

27. American Idol is rigged! Paula Abdul proved it tonight when they were supposed to be critiquing the first song of the two, and then she began critiquing him on his second song he hadn’t even sang yet.

She’s either wasted on drugs or had one too many drinks. Vote her off the show. Amazing how Simon jumped in and saved her from self destruct. Even when she was standing and dancig she looked intoxicated.

kiss, kiss, kiss to David Archuletta is what she wanted to do tonight with him. How she gave him such great props when we all know he sucks big time.

Has anyone noticed that Archuletta takes a breath during his words in his songs? Whow would want to listne to a song when you have to hear the singer taking a deep breath throughout it? Not me!

Posted at 2:33AM on Apr 30th 2008 by Noah

28. What a drug addict. TV promotes these people. Instead of letting them hit rock bottom...
She needs rehab.

Posted at 1:19AM on Apr 30th 2008 by jessup

29. Again. TMZ... Why have you not nailed that pain in the As* guy from CSI? He got busted in Palm Springs.. He has been a real jerk to your crew. X-17 has it.. I want to see you paint the full picture of this lovable jerk ..

Posted at 1:50AM on Apr 30th 2008 by SS

30. PROOF POSITIVE THAT THE POWERS THAT BE HATE JASON FOR HIS ORIGINALITY...BUT THE DREADHEADS WILL ROAR TONIGHT....THEY WILL NOT GET THE POP PRINCE THEY WANT...DC/JC FINALE BABEE

Posted at 9:22AM on Apr 30th 2008 by KALI