Fantasia -- If You Can't Say Something Nice ...
The judges didn't weigh in after Fantasia's interesting performance on "American Idol" last night -- but Simon's thoughts were written all over his face.
What a lovely shade of Detroit Hair Show red!
Relevant Posts
- Waiter Rains Beer on Simon's Birthday Parade (10/04/2009) (30 comments)
- Adam Lambert: I Respect GMA's Decision, But ... (11/24/2009) (354 comments)
- Adam Lambert -- Sucks Face to Save Face (10/14/2009) (152 comments)
- Adam Lambert Keeps His Tongue in His Mouth (11/25/2009) (44 comments)
- TMZ Live -- Ryan Seacrest, You're On! (11/12/2009) (32 comments)
Reader Comments
(Page 3 of 12) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments31. I was embarrassed watching her. It was hideous!! Why would they allow that type of performance? She personified everything negative about the black culture.
Posted at 9:34AM on May 15th 2008 by gordon147
32. She grossed me out so badly that I had to change the channel! Simon's reaction couldn't have been any worse than mine, I hope she doesn't come back ever to AI
Posted at 9:40AM on May 15th 2008 by pbsareredhot
33. OMG! Fantastia was Fanhorrible. She looked like a cow, sounded like she was in labor (grunting, groaning, nothing remotely resembling singing), & was a true train wreck. The hair, the outfit, the lack of talent. Why on earth did she ever win? Simon's reaction was priceless. She should never ever have won Idol - or even a county fair singing contest. What a mess.
Posted at 9:38AM on May 15th 2008 by SolFetch
34. OMG, Simon's reactions were priceless!! Hilarious!
Posted at 9:33AM on May 15th 2008 by Mairi
35. I tired of muppet voice when she was a contestant. Can't stand her whole act. Very cocky. I thought her performance was as Simon might say "indulgent". Waste of time.
Posted at 9:36AM on May 15th 2008 by Elliott
36. What a HORROR SHOW. But, as Ryan says "America voted......." We deserve what we get.
Posted at 9:41AM on May 15th 2008 by Robin
37. Fantasia's pink hair "Don't" - $5
Hooker Clothes -$10 (Sale at Big Lots)
Simon's expression - PRICELESS
She is a hot mess. WTF is all I can muster? Live TV is a Bit*h sometimes...Aint it!!!!
LOL
Posted at 9:43AM on May 15th 2008 by Cyn
38. This he/she just does nothing for me. Really s/he doesnt. Thanks God for DVR! I got to fast forward so I didnt have to watch its ugly ass!
Posted at 9:46AM on May 15th 2008 by I think shes a he!
39. I thought that she did something that was different!! Rem: we voted for her.
Posted at 9:49AM on May 15th 2008 by yoogirl
40. HIDEOUS!!! I don't think I've ever seen a more horrible performance from a so-called legitimate singer . I barely understood three words she screamed. She was a bad choice as an American Idol...and she's only gone downhill since then.
Posted at 9:49AM on May 15th 2008 by JT
41. OMG!!! She was awful!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She screamed all the way.. She should have never won is right!!!! I was embarrased for her.. The only ones that deserved American Idol is Carrie Underwood, and of course David Cook is the winner this year without a doubt... Go David!!! My fingers are going to fall off voting for him next week ha ha
Posted at 9:49AM on May 15th 2008 by Carol
42. She's a skank. I find it hard to beleive that she won a season. Those that voted for this piece of trash
must not have any taste.
Posted at 9:49AM on May 15th 2008 by jb
43. I liked Fantasia when she was on the show but I have no idea who is giving her performance advice now. She looked and sounded awful. Very forced. Not a natural talent. The whole performance I kept thinking about Britney Spears choking on MTV. Fantasia did not do her career any favors.
Posted at 9:50AM on May 15th 2008 by Clay Aiken Fan
44. this butch is a hot tranny mess.
Posted at 9:50AM on May 15th 2008 by tony
45. Simon's reaction was one of shock and embarrassment. There's not one good thing to say about that (choke) perfomance. Who would hire/ pay to see such an amateurish hoochie?? Suckers, that's who.
Posted at 9:54AM on May 15th 2008 by rudewaitress
